178 entries
Foundations
The evidence method, the vacuum, and inertia from it.
01 · The evidence ladder
Abraham (Avi) Loeb
Frank B. Baird Jr. Professor of Science, Harvard University; head of the Galileo Project
ResearcherInsists the argument be settled with instruments and known physics first - which is exactly how a genuine anomaly would be recognised if it is there.
- Overview of the Galileo Project (2023) — With Frank Laukien; the instrumentation and data-analysis design for all-sky anomaly search.
- Physical Constraints on Unidentified Aerial Phenomena (2023) — With Sean Kirkpatrick; works out what a high-acceleration object must emit, which is the strongest available test of any craft report.
The evidence ladderInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
Adam G. Riess
Nobel laureate who measured the acceleration that made vacuum energy an observational subject
ResearcherBefore 1998 the vacuum's energy was a theorist's headache; Riess's supernova measurement turned it into something the sky is measurably doing, and everything in this fold is downstream of that.
- Observational Evidence from Supernovae for an Accelerating Universe and a Cosmological Constant (1998) — Astronomical Journal 116, 1009-1038; 16 high-redshift supernovae came in 10-15% farther than a matter-only universe allows, favouring a positive cosmological constant.
Daniel L. Jassby
retired principal research physicist; writer on the practical limits of fusion energy
CriticJassby sharpens the question every fusion claim has to answer: after the plant powers itself, how much electricity is actually left over.
- Fusion reactors: Not what they're cracked up to be (2017) — The standard reference for the tritium, neutron-damage and parasitic-power objections.
- Twelve Axioms of Fusion Energy R&D (2020) — A compact checklist any fusion claim can be run against.
- The Quest for Fusion Energy (2022) — A longer historical review of why the timelines keep slipping.
Emilio Santos
theoretical physicist; co-founder of stochastic optics
ResearcherWith Marshall he built the most serious attempt to keep the vacuum real and local, and the precise way it strains is itself instructive.
- Stochastic optics: A local realistic analysis of optical tests of Bell inequalities (1989) — With Trevor Marshall: the central paper of stochastic optics.
- Bell's theorem: Local realism versus quantum mechanics (1990) — A pedagogical account of exactly what a real-vacuum theory has to overcome.
- Stochastic electrodynamics and the interpretation of quantum theory (2012) — A working physicist's survey of what SED explains and what still defeats it.
The evidence ladderWhat the vacuum isThe unified pictureEnergy from the vacuum
Garry P. Nolan
professor of pathology, Stanford University School of Medicine; materials analysis of anomalous samples
ResearcherBrings atom-level instrumentation and a strict chain of custody to physical samples - the only way material claims ever become evidence.
- Improved instrumental techniques, including isotopic analysis, applicable to the characterization of unusual materials with potential relevance to aerospace forensics (2022) — With Vallée, Jiang and Lemke; sets out how to analyse a claimed anomalous sample so the result means something.
The evidence ladderInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
Herman Batelaan
professor of physics, University of Nebraska-Lincoln; experimental and computational tests of stochastic electrodynamics
ResearcherHe is one of the few people asking how you could tell experimentally whether the vacuum field is real, rather than only arguing about it on paper.
- Discrete Excitation Spectrum of a Classical Harmonic Oscillator in Zero-Point Radiation (2015) — With Wayne Huang: a purely classical oscillator bathed in zero-point radiation is shown to develop discrete-looking excitations.
- Testing Quantum Coherence in Stochastic Electrodynamics with Squeezed Schrödinger Cat States (2019) — Proposes a concrete experimental test that could separate stochastic electrodynamics from standard quantum mechanics.
- Dynamics Underlying the Gaussian Distribution of the Classical Harmonic Oscillator in Zero-Point Radiation (2013) — The simulation work behind the claim that vacuum-driven classical motion reproduces quantum ground-state statistics.
The evidence ladderWhat the vacuum isScalar waves and the field behind the fieldsInertia and gravity from the vacuum
Jacques F. Vallée
computer scientist and astronomer; long-running physical analysis of UAP-associated materials and luminosity
ResearcherSixty years of insisting on physical measurements and case documentation rather than belief - and he publishes the null results too.
- Physical Analyses in Ten Cases of Unexplained Aerial Objects with Material Samples (1998) — The first systematic attempt to treat claimed physical residues as a laboratory problem.
- Estimates of Optical Power Output in Six Cases of Unexplained Aerial Objects with Defined Luminosity Characteristics (1998) — Puts numbers on radiated power - directly relevant to any energy-budget argument about propulsion.
- Improved instrumental techniques, including isotopic analysis (2022) — With Nolan; the modern methodology paper.
The evidence ladderPlasmoids, charge clusters and the orbsInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
Jed Rothwell / LENR-CANR.org
Librarian of the cold-fusion literature; maintains the free full-text archive of the field's papers
CommunityEvery argument in chapter twelve should be checked against the actual papers, and this is where they are – free, indexed and complete.
- Brief Introduction to Cold Fusion (2015) — 192,213 views; the standard short introduction to the experimental claims.
- LENR-CANR.org paper library (2026) — The field's primary full-text archive, free to read.
Katherine (Katie) Mack
Cosmologist and science communicator holding a chair dedicated to explaining this material to the public
EducatorMack makes the stakes vivid: whether the vacuum's energy stays constant or changes is literally the question of how everything ends, and she tells that story without losing the physics.
- The End of Everything (Astrophysically Speaking) (2020) — Five ways the universe could end, including vacuum decay and the heat death driven by dark energy — the most approachable account of why the vacuum's energy decides our cosmic fate.
Kazuki Ikeda
assistant professor of physics, University of Massachusetts Boston
ResearcherHe put the whole vacuum-energy-extraction experiment on GitHub, so a reader with a free IBM Quantum account can reproduce it rather than take anyone's word for it.
- Demonstration of Quantum Energy Teleportation on Superconducting Quantum Hardware (2023) — The first run of the energy-teleportation protocol on real IBM quantum processors, matching the exact theoretical prediction.
- Quantum-Energy-Teleportation (code repository) (2023) — Complete, runnable code for the experiment, on a laptop simulator or on IBM hardware — an unusually open invitation to reproduce the result yourself.
Kirk L. Shanahan
chemist; author of the calibration-constant-shift explanation for reported excess heat
CriticShanahan sharpens the one question calorimetry cannot dodge: whether the heat is real or the calibration moved.
- A systematic error in mass flow calorimetry demonstrated (2002) — The paper that proposes an ordinary chemical explanation for the heat measurements.
- Comments on 'Thermal behavior of polarized Pd/D electrodes prepared by co-deposition' (2005) — His direct challenge to the Navy co-deposition results.
- Reply to 'Comment on papers by K. Shanahan that propose to explain anomalous heat generation' (2006) — The published exchange, which is the clearest way to see both sides argue.
Lawrence H. Ford
professor of physics, Tufts University; quantum inequalities and the limits on negative energy
CriticHis quantum inequalities put a number on how much negative energy you can borrow from the vacuum and for how long, which is the single most useful constraint anyone designing a vacuum engine has to meet.
- Research on Gravity and Quantum Fluctuation Effects (2015) — $50,000 from August 2015; his long-running programme on how much negative energy the vacuum will actually allow, and for how long.
- Averaged Energy Conditions and Quantum Inequalities (1995) — With Thomas Roman, the paper that turned 'you can't have unlimited negative energy' into a precise inequality.
- Restrictions on Negative Energy Density in Flat Spacetime (1997) — Sets the quantitative budget every exotic-matter proposal has to work inside.
The evidence ladderWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuumThe metric, warp drives and wormholes
Matthew Szydagis
associate professor of physics, University at Albany (SUNY); dark-matter detector physicist leading UAPx instrumentation
ResearcherBrings particle-detector discipline - blind analysis, calibration, stated systematics - to a subject that badly needed it.
- Initial results from the first field expedition of UAPx to study unidentified anomalous phenomena (2025) — With Knuth, Kugielsky and Levy; a peer-reviewed field methodology using cameras, radar data and radiation detectors instead of testimony.
The evidence ladderInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
Michael Dittmar
particle physicist writing critically on the feasibility and timelines of fusion energy
CriticDittmar sharpens the question of what any fusion programme, orthodox or otherwise, would have to demonstrate before it counts as energy.
- Fusion Illusions (2008) — The chapter-length case that fusion timelines have never been met and why.
- Nuclear energy: status and future limitations (2012) — The resource and engineering constraints, worked through.
Michael S. Turner
Chicago cosmologist who named dark energy and argued early for a live cosmological constant
ResearcherTurner supplied the vocabulary the whole field now uses, and the observational strategy for deciding whether 'dark energy' and 'vacuum energy' are the same thing.
- Prospects for probing the dark energy via supernova distance measurements (1999) — With Dragan Huterer; Phys. Rev. D 60, 081301 — an early use of the term 'dark energy' and a programme for telling a constant vacuum energy apart from an evolving field.
- The Cosmological Constant is Back (1995) — With Lawrence M. Krauss; Gen. Rel. Grav. 27, 1137-1144.
Mick West
science writer and investigator; founder of the Metabunk forum
CriticHis geometry work sets the bar a sighting must clear before it counts as a propulsion datum - which is what makes the surviving cases interesting.
- Sitrec - situation recreation tool (2023) — Open-source 3D reconstruction of camera geometry, so anyone can check a claimed velocity themselves.
- Quick Guide to Modern Video Analysis Techniques for UAP (and UFOs) (2024) — A practical method paper: parallax, gimbal rotation, glare, and how each fools the eye.
- Escaping the Rabbit Hole (2018) — On how to argue about evidence without losing the person you are arguing with.
Paul J. Steinhardt
Princeton cosmologist pressing the case that the standard constant-Lambda picture is not what the data demand
CriticSteinhardt sharpens the most consequential question in this chunk: are we reading real physics out of the supernova and survey data, or reading our own parameter choices back out of them?
- Assessing observational constraints on dark energy (2024) — Physics Letters B 855, 138826; shows the standard w0-wa parameterisation is nearly degenerate, so an apparent preference for evolving dark energy can be an artefact of the fitting framework rather than evidence about the vacuum.
- Rapidly Descending Dark Energy and the End of Cosmic Expansion (2022) — PNAS 119, e2200539119 — if dark energy is a rolling field rather than a constant, cosmic expansion could end far sooner than the standard picture implies.
Peter A. Sturrock
professor emeritus of applied physics, Stanford University; founder of the Society for Scientific Exploration
ResearcherBuilt the institution that lets careful people publish on anomalies at all - the reason a Journal of Scientific Exploration exists.
- The UFO Enigma: A New Review of the Physical Evidence (1999) — A physicist-led review panel's attempt to say what the physical evidence does and does not support.
- Report on a survey of the membership of the American Astronomical Society concerning the UFO problem (1977) — The survey that showed working astronomers were more interested than they were willing to say publicly.
The evidence ladderInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
Peter W. Milonni
theoretical physicist, Los Alamos National Laboratory (retired); author of the standard textbook on the quantum vacuum
ResearcherIf you read one book to understand the vacuum as physics rather than as metaphor, it is his, and he writes about zero-point energy without either hype or dismissal.
- The Quantum Vacuum: An Introduction to Quantum Electrodynamics (1994) — The standard textbook on what the quantum vacuum is and what it demonstrably does; chapters include 'Zero-Point Energy in Early Quantum Theory' and the Casimir and van der Waals treatments.
- The Casimir Effect: Physical Manifestations of Zero-Point Energy (2003) — A Physics Today piece that is the best short bridge between the technical literature and a general reader.
- Zero-Point Energy (2009) — His encyclopedia entry — a compact, authoritative definition to anchor any discussion.
Progress in Aerospace Sciences (as a UAP-physics venue)
mainstream Elsevier review journal that since 2021 has published peer-reviewed UAP and anomalous-flight research
EducatorThe clearest sign that anomalous-flight physics has entered the ordinary literature - and the citations are checkable.
- The new science of Unidentified Aerospace-Undersea Phenomena (UAP) (2025) — Knuth and 33 co-authors; the field's first large peer-reviewed synthesis in a conventional aerospace journal.
- Improved instrumental techniques, including isotopic analysis (2022) — Nolan and Vallée on how to analyse a claimed anomalous material.
- Initial results from the first field expedition of UAPx (2025) — Szydagis and colleagues; instrumented fieldwork with a pre-registered protocol.
The evidence ladderInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craftPlasmoids, charge clusters and the orbs
Robert M. Powell
physicist and co-founder of the Scientific Coalition for UAP Studies; co-author of the flight-characteristics papers
ResearcherTurns raw case files into numbers a propulsion physicist can argue with - and says plainly when the data cannot bear the weight.
- Estimating Flight Characteristics of Anomalous Unidentified Aerial Vehicles (2019) — With Knuth and Reali; the acceleration and power estimates, with stated uncertainties.
- UFOs: A Scientist Explains What We Know (And Don't Know) (2021) — A careful separation of what the data supports from what it does not.
The evidence ladderInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
Ruth Durrer
Geneva cosmologist who asks what the observations genuinely establish about dark energy
CriticDurrer sharpens the evidence question underneath everything else here: how many independent measurements really point at dark energy, and what would it take to add a genuinely new one?
- What do we really know about Dark Energy? (2011) — Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 369, 5102-5114; an invited Kavli Royal Society talk arguing that supernovae, the microwave background and baryon acoustic oscillations all rest on the same single distance-redshift observation.
Sabine Hossenfelder
theoretical physicist and science communicator; frequent critic of propellantless-drive and vacuum-energy claims
CriticNames the specific conservation law or measurement error a claim has to survive - the fastest way to find the weak joint in any proposal.
- Backreaction blog (2026) — Where the technical objections are stated at length, with references.
- Lost in Math: How Beauty Leads Physics Astray (2018) — Useful context: her critique cuts at mainstream theory too, not only at outsiders.
- Some UAPs Might Be Warp Drives, Physicists Say (2026) — Covers the recent warp-signature literature; 583k views in under a week.
The evidence ladderInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craftThe metric, warp drives and wormholesWhat the vacuum is
Sean M. Carroll
Physicist and broadcaster whose review and podcast are many people's first serious contact with vacuum energy
EducatorCarroll wrote one of the standard open-access reviews and then spent two decades explaining it out loud — the shortest path from curiosity about empty space to the actual physics literature.
- The Cosmological Constant (2001) — Living Reviews in Relativity 4:1 — a pedagogical overview of cosmology with a cosmological constant, the observational limits on it, and the physics of a small non-zero vacuum energy.
Sean M. Kirkpatrick
physicist; founding director of the US All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO), 2022-2023
CriticSharpens the question every propulsion claim must answer: if it accelerates like that, where is the heat, the shock and the radio signature?
- Physical Constraints on Unidentified Aerial Phenomena (2023) — With Loeb; the known-physics boundary conditions any propulsion claim has to satisfy.
- Testimony to the Senate Armed Services Committee (2023) — The official statement of what the US government's own review did and did not find.
- Ultrafast holographic nanopatterning of biocatalytically formed silica (2001) — A Nature paper - Kirkpatrick is a working physicist, which matters when weighing his assessments.
The evidence ladderInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craftPlasmoids, charge clusters and the orbs
Theodorus M. Nieuwenhuizen
theoretical physicist, Institute of Physics, University of Amsterdam
ResearcherHe works on the exact point where the real-vacuum picture either succeeds or breaks — whether it can hold an atom together — and reports the result either way.
- Stochastic Electrodynamics: Renormalized Noise in the Hydrogen Ground-State Problem (2020) — Tackles the problem that has defeated stochastic electrodynamics for decades — keeping a classical hydrogen atom stable in a vacuum field.
- Simulation of the hydrogen ground state in stochastic electrodynamics (2015) — With Liska: the direct numerical attempt, reported honestly including where it fails.
- Stochastic Electrodynamics: Lessons from Regularizing the Harmonic Oscillator (2019) — Draws out what the solvable case teaches about the unsolved one.
The evidence ladderWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumEnergy from the vacuum
Trevor W. Marshall
mathematician and physicist; co-founder of stochastic optics
ResearcherHe pressed the hardest question you can ask of the real-vacuum picture — whether it survives Bell's theorem — and published the attempt rather than avoiding it.
- Stochastic optics: A local realistic analysis of optical tests of Bell inequalities (1989) — With Emilio Santos: asks how far a real zero-point field can reproduce the results usually taken as proof that no such field exists.
- Bell's theorem: Local realism versus quantum mechanics (1990) — With Ferrero and Santos, written for the American Journal of Physics and therefore unusually readable.
- Random electrodynamics (1963) — Proceedings of the Royal Society A - the paper that made the zero-point field a classical physical field rather than a quantum bookkeeping term.
The evidence ladderWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuumInertia and gravity from the vacuum
Yefim S. Levin
physicist who published the detailed critical analysis of the zero-point-field inertia theory
CriticHis paper sharpens the central question of this chapter — whether the zero-point field really produces the reaction force we call inertia — by checking the derivation step by step rather than arguing about it.
- Inertia as a zero-point-field force: Critical analysis of the Haisch-Rueda-Puthoff inertia theory (2009) — A line-by-line examination of the vacuum-inertia derivation, published in the same journal as the original claim.
- Some theoretical aspects of observation of acceleration induced thermality (2025) — Recent Physical Review D work on whether an accelerated observer really sees a warm vacuum.
The evidence ladderInertia and gravity from the vacuumEnergy from the vacuum
All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO)
US Department of Defense office responsible for resolving reported anomalous phenomena
CriticThe official counterweight: knowing what the government says it found is part of reading the propulsion documents honestly. Site blocked automated access on the date checked.
- Report on the Historical Record of U.S. Government Involvement with UAP, Volume I (2024) — The government's own account of programmes including AAWSAP, which commissioned the propulsion DIRDs.
- Annual Report on Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (2024) — The official case-resolution statistics, useful as a baseline for how many reports are explained.
- Director's oral remarks to the Senate Armed Services Committee (2023) — Sean Kirkpatrick's testimony to the SASC Emerging Threats and Capabilities subcommittee, 19 April 2023 - obtained directly from the Senate's own document server.
The evidence ladderInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craftPlasmoids, charge clusters and the orbs
Archimedes experiment (INFN)
The experiment actually trying to weigh vacuum energy, using a Casimir cavity on a balance
ResearcherThis is the experiment that turns the whole argument into a measurement: put a Casimir cavity on a balance, switch its vacuum modes on and off, and see whether gravity notices. Whatever the answer, it is data rather than debate.
- The Archimedes experiment (2015) — Enrico Calloni and 16 collaborators; sets out the plan to measure the gravitational force on a Casimir cavity whose vacuum energy is modulated by a superconducting transition.
- Thermal noise-limited beam balance as prototype of the Archimedes vacuum weight experiment (2024) — Eur. Phys. J. Plus 139, 158, first author A. Allocca — the prototype balance reaching thermal-noise-limited sensitivity.
- Weighing the Quantum Vacuum: Latest Progress and Experimental Status of the Archimedes Experiment (2026) — Most recent status report found; arXiv identifier not confirmed on the pages opened.
The evidence ladderWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumEnergy from the vacuum
DESI (Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument) collaboration
The survey now testing whether dark energy is constant vacuum energy at all
ResearcherIf dark energy turns out to change with time, it cannot simply be the constant energy of empty space — DESI is the instrument currently deciding that, and its DR2 numbers are the ones to watch.
- DESI DR2 Results II: Measurements of Baryon Acoustic Oscillations and Cosmological Constraints (2025) — Nearly 15 million galaxies and quasars; a time-evolving dark energy model is preferred over a plain cosmological constant at 3.1 sigma with the cosmic microwave background, and 2.8-4.2 sigma once supernovae are added.
ESA Advanced Concepts Team
The European Space Agency's in-house think tank, with standing research lines in fundamental physics and propulsion
ResearcherEurope's equivalent of NIAC - the place ESA parks the questions that are too early for a mission but too important to ignore.
- ACT research lines including Fundamental Physics and Propulsion (2026) — ESA maintains a permanent team whose brief is explicitly to look at concepts that could be disruptive, including fundamental physics.
The evidence ladderInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
Scientific Coalition for UAP Studies (SCU)
volunteer scientific organisation producing technical UAP case studies and analyses
ResearcherWhere the raw radar, video and witness material gets turned into something a physicist can put numbers on.
- A Forensic Analysis of Navy Carrier Strike Group Eleven's Encounter with an Anomalous Aerial Vehicle (2019) — The Nimitz analysis that Knuth's flight-characteristics papers build on.
- The Flight Characteristics and Physics of UAP - Kevin Knuth (AIAA AV21 UAP session) (2021) — Knuth's acceleration and power analysis presented at an AIAA session.
- Kevin Knuth: The Scientific Study of Unidentified Aerospace-Undersea Phenomena (2026) — Updated version of the same analysis.
The evidence ladderInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
Society for UAP Studies
academic society publishing the peer-reviewed journal Limina
EducatorSignals that this subject can carry ordinary academic apparatus - review, citation, disagreement in print.
- Limina: The Journal of UAP Studies (2023) — A peer-reviewed venue explicitly open to the physics of anomalous flight.
The evidence ladderInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
The Galileo Project
Harvard-based programme building all-sky observatories to characterise anomalous objects with instruments
ResearcherunverifiedReplaces argument with a data pipeline - if there is an anomalous flight signature to find, this is the kind of instrument that would find it. Site blocked automated access on the date checked.
- Overview of the Galileo Project (2023) — The design document: infrared, optical, radio and audio, all-sky, with machine-learning outlier detection.
- Galileo Project publications (2026) — The project's peer-reviewed output on instrumented sky surveys.
- The Galileo Project observatory instrumentation papers (2023) — Published in a refereed instrumentation journal - the project's defining commitment is that the data must be collected by known instruments with known calibration.
The evidence ladderInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craftPlasmoids, charge clusters and the orbs
The Sol Foundation
research and policy institute on UAP, co-founded by Garry Nolan and Peter Skafish
ResearcherThe place where the physics of anomalous flight is discussed alongside what would follow if any of it is real.
- Sol Foundation Inaugural Symposium proceedings (2023) — Brought physicists, historians and policy people into one recorded programme on the propulsion question.
- The Sol Forum - with Hal Puthoff, Jacques Vallée, and Larry Lemke (2025) — Puthoff, Vallée and former NASA engineer Larry Lemke in one conversation; 38k views.
- Sol Foundation Symposium archive (2026) — Academic talks from the annual symposium.
The evidence ladderInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
UAPx
non-profit scientific research organisation running instrumented UAP field expeditions
ResearcherDemonstrates that this subject can be done as instrumented fieldwork with a published protocol - the standard the site should hold everyone to.
- Initial results from the first field expedition of UAPx (2025) — The Laguna Beach 2021 campaign, with the data-handling protocol written down in advance.
The evidence ladderInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
03 · What the vacuum is
Alexander O. Sushkov
physicist, Boston University; precision quantum measurement
ResearcherHe led the measurement that put temperature into the Casimir story — the strand of the vacuum force that theory still argues about.
- Observation of the thermal Casimir force (2011) — Lead author on the Nature Physics report of the temperature-dependent Casimir force, with Kim, Dalvit and Lamoreaux (arXiv:1011.5219).
Alfonso Rueda
professor of electrical engineering and physics, California State University Long Beach; zero-point field theorist
ProponentHe did the hard mathematics behind the claim that mass and weight are things the vacuum does to matter, and he published it in mainstream journals.
- Inertia as a zero-point-field Lorentz force (1994) — With Haisch and Puthoff: the Physical Review A paper proposing inertia as a vacuum reaction force.
- Vacuum zero-point field pressure instability in astrophysical plasmas and the formation of cosmic voids (1995) — Takes the vacuum-pressure idea to astrophysical scale in The Astrophysical Journal.
- Stochastic nonrelativistic approach to gravity as originating from vacuum zero-point field van der Waals forces (2001) — With Cole and Danley: gravity modelled as a residual vacuum force.
What the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumEnergy from the vacuum
Alfred Leitenstorfer
ultrafast physicist, University of Konstanz; direct electro-optic sampling of vacuum fluctuations
ResearcherHis group did the thing that sounds impossible: measured the electric field of empty space directly, without absorbing a single photon.
- Direct sampling of electric-field vacuum fluctuations (2015) — Science, with Riek, Seletskiy, Moskalenko and colleagues — reads out the vacuum's own electric field with femtosecond pulses, no cavity and no photon absorption.
- Back action in quantum electro-optic sampling of electromagnetic vacuum fluctuations (2023) — How the measurement itself disturbs the vacuum it is measuring (arXiv:2202.03353).
- Realizing a rapidly switched Unruh-DeWitt detector through electro-optic sampling (2022) — Turns the sampling technique into a laboratory version of a relativistic particle detector (arXiv:2103.14360).
Amedeo Balbi
Italian astrophysicist (Università di Roma Tor Vergata) on vacuum energy and the warp drive
ResearcherAn actual cosmologist telling Italian readers the vacuum energy problem is unsolved, not embarrassing trivia.
- L'energia del vuoto: uno dei più grandi enigmi della fisica moderna (2025) — 288,085 views; a cosmologist's statement of the vacuum-energy problem in Italian.
- Il motore a curvatura di Star Trek: il Warp Drive di Alcubierre (2020) — 561,951 views.
Ana María Cetto
theoretical physicist, Instituto de Física, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México
ResearcherHalf of the partnership that produced the most complete book-length case that the vacuum field is what makes matter behave quantum-mechanically.
- The Emerging Quantum: The Physics Behind Quantum Mechanics (2015) — The standard modern reference for the zero-point-field derivation of quantum mechanics.
- Linear stochastic electrodynamics: Looking for the physics behind quantum theory (1999) — A clear statement of what the programme is trying to explain and why.
- Completing the Quantum Ontology with the Electromagnetic Zero-Point Field (2024) — Places the zero-point field alongside pilot-wave approaches as a candidate account of what is physically going on.
What the vacuum isThe unified pictureEnergy from the vacuumInertia and gravity from the vacuum
Andrea Cavalleri
founding director, Max Planck Institute for the Structure and Dynamics of Matter; professor of physics, University of Oxford
ResearcherHe established that superconductivity is something you can induce and enhance by controlling a material's electromagnetic environment, which is exactly what the dark-cavity experiments now do with no light at all.
- Light-Induced Superconductivity in a Stripe-Ordered Cuprate (2011) — Showed superconductivity can be switched on by driving a material's lattice, opening the whole programme of engineering superconductivity rather than merely finding it.
- Nonlinear lattice dynamics as a basis for enhanced superconductivity in YBa2Cu3O6.5 (2014) — Extended the effect to a high-temperature cuprate, establishing the field the later vacuum-cavity work grew out of.
Andrea Valdés-Hernández
theoretical physicist, Instituto de Física, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México
ResearcherShe carries the zero-point-field programme into its hardest test, entanglement, which is where most classical-vacuum accounts are expected to fail.
- The Emerging Quantum: The Physics Behind Quantum Mechanics (2015) — Third author of the school's central book, and the one who carried the programme into questions of entanglement.
- Quantum Mechanics as an Emergent Property of Ergodic Systems Embedded in the Zero-point Radiation Field (2009) — Sets out the ergodic argument for how a system immersed in vacuum radiation acquires quantum statistics.
Andrew J. Millis
professor of physics, Columbia University; co-director, Center for Computational Quantum Physics, Flatiron Institute
ResearcherOne of the most respected theorists of superconductivity now puts his name to cavity-vacuum engineering, which tells a reader how seriously the field is being taken.
- Cavity-enhanced superconducting response in an underdoped cuprate (2026) — Co-author; his involvement signals that vacuum-cavity engineering has entered mainstream correlated-electron theory.
- Nonequilibrium orders in parametrically driven field theories (2025) — Driving a field theory parametrically is the same idea behind the dynamical Casimir effect.
Ángel Rubio
director of the Theory Department, Max Planck Institute for the Structure and Dynamics of Matter
ResearcherHe built the computational machinery (QEDFT) that lets you predict, from first principles, what a material will do when you change the vacuum around it.
- Cavity-enhanced superconductivity in the two-dimensional limit of NbSe2 (2026) — Supplied the first-principles theory showing cavity coupling redistributes spectral weight in the Eliashberg function, which explains the non-monotonic frequency dependence.
- Macroscopic Polarization and Magnetization from Cavity Vacuum Fluctuations (2026) — Vacuum fluctuations alone are shown to induce macroscopic polarization in a material — a bulk effect from empty space.
- Symmetry Rules for Cavity Materials Engineering with Linearly Polarized Vacuum Fields (2026) — Gives the symmetry conditions that say which materials will respond to a shaped vacuum, turning trial-and-error into design.
Astrid Lambrecht
theoretical physicist, Forschungszentrum Jülich and RWTH Aachen (formerly Laboratoire Kastler Brossel, Paris)
ResearcherShe is pushing the Casimir force somewhere unexpected — biology — asking whether the vacuum helps hold living structures together.
- Casimir effect with dielectric matter in salted water and implications at the cell scale (2026) — Takes the Casimir force out of the vacuum chamber and into salty biological fluid (arXiv:2601.09020).
- Universal Casimir attraction between filaments at the cell scale (2024) — New J. Phys. 26, 013009 — argues the vacuum force is strong enough to matter inside cells (arXiv:2306.14059).
- Universal Casimir interactions in the sphere–sphere geometry (2022) — The scattering approach applied to the geometry experiments actually use.
Barry W. Ninham
professor, Department of Materials Physics, Australian National University
ProponentHe has argued for decades that the same vacuum-fluctuation forces measured between mirrors are quietly running chemistry and biology — a claim that makes the Casimir effect feel much closer to home.
- ANU research profile: dispersion potentials, Hofmeister effects and polarizability (2025) — The profile page documenting his continuing programme on dispersion (Lifshitz-Casimir-type) forces in real chemistry.
- Matthew Flinders Medal and Lecture, Australian Academy of Science (2017) — Recognition of a career spent insisting that Lifshitz-Casimir forces govern ordinary colloid and biological chemistry.
Caterina Braggio
experimental physicist, University of Padua / INFN Padova
ResearcherShe works on the most vivid version of the idea — a mirror moved fast enough that empty space itself glows — and on the detectors sensitive enough to catch it.
- MIR: An experiment for the measurement of the dynamical Casimir effect (2009) — The experiment built to convert vacuum fluctuations into detectable microwave photons by rapidly modulating a mirror.
- Optomechanical Rydberg-atom excitation via dynamic Casimir-Polder coupling (2014) — A proposal to see the dynamical Casimir-Polder force by coupling an oscillating mirror to Rydberg atoms.
Changgan Zeng
professor of physics, University of Science and Technology of China
ResearcherHe co-led the 2026 result that turned the vacuum from a passive backdrop into an engineering variable you can tune to make a material superconduct better.
- Evidence for vacuum-enhanced superconductivity in NbSe2 (2026) — Co-led the first experiment in which the vacuum field alone, with no light applied, raised a superconductor's transition temperature.
- Magnetic-field tuning of the Casimir force (2021) — Reported that an applied magnetic field changes the measured Casimir force - a direct experimental handle on the vacuum.
- Reply to: Re-examining magnetic tuning of Casimir forces (2023) — The published exchange with critics, which is where the real evidence gets tested.
Christopher M. Wilson
experimental physicist, Institute for Quantum Computing, University of Waterloo
ResearcherHe is the experimentalist who made empty space emit light on demand, so his papers are the place to see what the vacuum actually does when you shake it.
- Observation of the Dynamical Casimir Effect in a Superconducting Circuit (2011) — The first laboratory conversion of vacuum fluctuations into real, detectable photons, using a SQUID as a mirror moved at a large fraction of light speed.
Claus W. Turtur
German physicist (Ostfalia University of Applied Sciences) publishing on space-energy (Raumenergie) converters
ResearcherA tenured German engineering physicist who took the zero-point field seriously enough to build rotors and publish the energy accounting – the German counterpart to the Anglophone ZPE experimentalists.
- 1-kW Raumenergie-Konverter – Prof. Dr. Claus Turtur (2015) — 93,009 views on ExoMagazinTV; Turtur presents the converter design and its energy balance.
- Claus Turtur: Freie Energie – Nullpunktsenergie des Quanten-Vakuums (2014) — Lecture framing zero-point energy of the quantum vacuum as an engineering target.
Daniel C. Cole
professor of mechanical engineering, Boston University; thermodynamics of the zero-point field
ResearcherHe is the person who takes the thermodynamics seriously — if energy can be drawn from the vacuum, his papers are where you find out under what conditions and at what cost.
- Stochastic Electric Dipole Oscillator in a Nonuniform, Static Electric Field, used to Derive the Classical Electromagnetic Zero-point Radiation Spectrum (2026) — A 2026 derivation of the zero-point spectrum from classical thermodynamic reasoning.
- Applying the thermodynamics of a stochastic classical point charge in a spherical charge to derive classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation (2026) — Companion 2026 result reaching the same spectrum by a second route.
- Entropy Considerations in Stochastic Electrodynamics (2024) — Confronts the hardest question for any vacuum-energy scheme — what the second law permits.
What the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumEnergy from the vacuum
Daniele Fausti
experimental physicist, University of Trieste and Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg
ResearcherHis group extends vacuum-cavity enhancement from simple superconductors to the cuprates, the hardest and most consequential case.
- Cavity-enhanced superconducting response in an underdoped cuprate (2026) — Senior author: an underdoped YBCO film inside a tunable terahertz cavity shows increased superfluid weight and a higher superconducting onset, and the effect strengthens as the cavity is made shorter.
- Controlling radiative heat flow through cavity electrodynamics (2024) — Heat moved by reshaping the vacuum field around a sample.
- Cavity-mediated thermal control of metal-to-insulator transition in 1T-TaS2 (2023) — An empty cavity changing when a crystal becomes a metal.
Dante M. Kennes
theoretical physicist, RWTH Aachen University
ResearcherHe works on the theory side of engineering materials through their electromagnetic environment, and writes the reviews that make the field legible.
- Cavity-enhanced superconducting response in an underdoped cuprate (2026) — Co-author on the modelling of cavity-strengthened superconducting phase stiffness.
- Floquet engineering magnetism and superconductivity in the square-lattice Hubbard model (2025) — Driving a material to change its ground state - the theoretical backbone of cavity materials engineering.
David J. Hilton
experimental physicist, Baylor University; ultrafast and terahertz spectroscopy
ResearcherHe is trying to turn vacuum photon creation from a demonstration into a tool — a source of entangled light — which is how a curiosity becomes a technology.
- EAGER: Entangled Light Generation via the Dynamical Casimir Effect (2024) — $158,500 from August 2024: an NSF-funded attempt to generate entangled light directly from vacuum fluctuations, which would make the dynamical Casimir effect a usable quantum-optics resource.
Denis V. Seletskiy
physicist, Polytechnique Montréal; leads the femtoQ laboratory
ResearcherHe co-authored the direct measurement of vacuum fluctuations and now runs the lab pushing that time-domain view of quantum fields further.
- Direct sampling of electric-field vacuum fluctuations (2015) — Science, as second author with Riek and Leitenstorfer — the first direct read-out of vacuum electric-field fluctuations.
- Time-domain perspective on quantum fields: role of indistinguishability (2026) — CLEO paper from femtoQ on how to think about quantum fields in the time domain.
- Kerr-induced non-Gaussianity of a bright ultrafast quantum state (2026) — Optica 13, 1232–1237 — engineering the quantum statistics of light itself (arXiv:2512.17797).
Eduardo Martín-Martínez
professor of applied mathematics, University of Waterloo; relativistic quantum information
ResearcherHis field, entanglement harvesting, is the study of how much correlation and energy two detectors can pull out of the bare vacuum simply by switching on — the theoretical backbone of this whole chapter.
- Experimental Activation of Strong Local Passive States with Quantum Information (2023) — Co-author on the first NMR realisation of the energy-teleportation protocol.
Francesco Intravaia
senior research fellow, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin (Theoretical Optics & Photonics, with the Max Born Institute)
ResearcherQuantum friction — the idea that empty space can drag on something that moves — is his speciality, and it is the strangest testable consequence of vacuum fluctuations.
- Casimir-Polder interaction between atoms and hollow-core fibers (2026) — Latest listed work: the vacuum force on an atom inside a hollow optical fibre.
- The power-spectrum tensor in steady-state systems and its role in quantum friction (2026) — Formal machinery for the drag a body feels moving through the vacuum near a surface.
- High-accuracy Casimir-Polder force calculations using the Discontinuous Galerkin Time-Domain method (2023) — Numerics good enough to predict vacuum forces in realistic nanostructures.
Francesco Piazza
theoretical physicist, University of Augsburg; cavity QED with many-body systems
ResearcherHe works out what happens when a whole many-body system, not a single atom, is coupled to the vacuum of a cavity — which is where collective vacuum effects become large enough to matter.
- Cavity-enhanced superconducting response in an underdoped cuprate (2026) — Co-author on the theoretical interpretation of cavity-strengthened superconductivity.
- Superradiant Topological Peierls Insulator inside an Optical Cavity (2017) — A cavity vacuum field reorganising matter into a new topological phase.
- Bose-Einstein condensation versus Dicke-Hepp-Lieb transition in an optical cavity (2013) — The superradiant phase transition is the textbook case of the vacuum changing state.
What the vacuum isGravity control and superconductorsEnergy from the vacuum
Franco Nori
chief scientist, Theoretical Quantum Physics Laboratory, RIKEN
ResearcherHis group writes the review articles that map the whole landscape of vacuum-fluctuation effects in engineered circuits, which is the fastest way into the field.
- Observation of the Dynamical Casimir Effect in a Superconducting Circuit (2011) — Co-author on the first observation; his group also produced much of the theoretical groundwork for circuit-based vacuum photon generation.
- Quantum Vacuum Radiation Near a Critical Point (2026) — Shows that driving a system non-adiabatically through a critical point converts virtual excitations into real photons, a fresh route to vacuum radiation.
Galina L. Klimchitskaya
theoretical physicist, Pulkovo Observatory and Peter the Great St Petersburg Polytechnic University
ResearcherShe has spent a career on the awkward part of the story — that the standard theory and the best measurements do not fully agree — and she keeps publishing the tests that could settle it.
- The Casimir force between real materials: Experiment and theory (2009) — Reviews of Modern Physics, with Mohideen and Mostepanenko — the canonical account of why real materials complicate the ideal Casimir picture.
- Advances in the Casimir Effect (2009) — Oxford monograph with Bordag, Mohideen and Mostepanenko; her most-cited work (1,817 citations on her Scholar profile).
- Thermal effect in the Casimir force for graphene and graphene-coated substrates (2017) — With Bimonte and Mostepanenko — graphene as the cleanest testbed for the thermal Casimir puzzle (arXiv:1709.02628).
Gerhard Grössing
theoretical physicist, Austrian Institute for Nonlinear Studies, Vienna; convener of the Emergent Quantum Mechanics conferences
ResearcherHe runs the meeting where everyone who thinks quantum mechanics emerges from a deeper vacuum medium actually argues it out in public.
- Sub-Quantum Thermodynamics as a Basis of Emergent Quantum Mechanics (2010) — Treats the vacuum as a thermodynamic medium whose fluctuations produce quantum behaviour, published open access in Entropy.
- The vacuum fluctuation theorem: Exact Schroedinger equation via nonequilibrium thermodynamics (2008) — Derives quantum mechanics from a particle exchanging energy with the vacuum.
- An explanation of interference effects in the double slit experiment: Classical trajectories plus ballistic diffusion caused by zero-point fluctuations (2012) — Annals of Physics - the double slit without wavefunction collapse.
Gheorghe-Sorin Paraoanu
associate professor, Department of Applied Physics, Aalto University
ResearcherHis Josephson-metamaterial version of the experiment shows the vacuum can be made to radiate by changing a medium's refractive index, not just by moving walls.
- Dynamical Casimir effect in a Josephson metamaterial (2013) — A second, independent route to vacuum photon creation: modulating the speed of light in a Josephson metamaterial rather than moving a mirror.
Giacomo Jarc
experimental physicist working on cavity control of quantum materials
ResearcherHe builds the adjustable cavities that let experimenters dial the vacuum and watch a material respond, which is how a vacuum effect gets separated from everything else.
- Cavity-enhanced superconducting response in an underdoped cuprate (2026) — Co-author on the cuprate cavity result; his tunable cavity design is what makes the length-dependence test possible.
- Cavity-mediated thermal control of metal-to-insulator transition in 1T-TaS2 (2023) — A Nature paper showing an empty cavity shifting a material's phase transition.
- Tunable cryogenic terahertz cavity for strong light-matter coupling in complex materials (2022) — The instrument that made the result possible.
Giovanni Carugno
experimental physicist, INFN Legnaro / Padova
ResearcherHe is part of the Italian group that went after the harder prize: not just measuring the vacuum's pull, but trying to make the vacuum emit light.
- Measurement of the Casimir force between parallel metallic surfaces (2002) — With Bressi, Onofrio and Ruoso — the parallel-plate Casimir measurement closest to Casimir's original picture.
- MIR: An experiment for the measurement of the dynamical Casimir effect (2009) — The Padova/Legnaro attempt to shake real photons out of the vacuum using a semiconductor mirror inside a superconducting cavity.
Giuseppe Bimonte
theoretical physicist, Università di Napoli Federico II / INFN Napoli
ResearcherHe is the theorist writing down what to look for next — including whether the vacuum force visibly changes the moment a metal becomes a superconductor.
- Surface scattering expansion of the Casimir-Polder interaction for magneto-dielectric bodies (2023) — With Thorsten Emig — a scattering method for real, rough, magnetic surfaces.
- Thermal effect in the Casimir force for graphene and graphene-coated substrates (2017) — With Klimchitskaya and Mostepanenko — graphene is where the disputed thermal Casimir effect should be largest (arXiv:1709.02628).
- Proposal to measure the Casimir effect across the superconducting transition (2025) — Predicts a jump in the Casimir force when a film goes superconducting — a measurable link between the vacuum and superconductivity.
Giuseppe Ruoso
experimental physicist, INFN Laboratori Nazionali di Legnaro
ResearcherFew people have tried to measure so many different faces of the vacuum — its pull, its glow, and whether it can act like a birefringent material.
- Measurement of the Casimir force between parallel metallic surfaces (2002) — Co-author of the parallel-plate Casimir measurement (arXiv:quant-ph/0203002).
- The PVLAS experiment: A 25 year effort to measure vacuum magnetic birefringence (2020) — Physics Reports 871, 1–74 — the full account of trying to see the vacuum bend light in a magnetic field (arXiv:2005.12913).
Göran Johansson
theoretical physicist, Applied Quantum Physics, Chalmers University of Technology
ResearcherHe supplies the theory that tells you how to recognise a genuine vacuum-conversion signal, which is the hardest part of any energy-from-the-vacuum claim.
- Observation of the Dynamical Casimir Effect in a Superconducting Circuit (2011) — Provided the circuit-QED theory that let the team identify the emitted radiation as vacuum-converted photons rather than ordinary noise.
- Dynamical Casimir Effect in a Superconducting Coplanar Waveguide (2009) — The Physical Review Letters proposal that made the experiment possible.
Guanghui Cheng
professor of physics, University of Science and Technology of China; lead experimentalist on vacuum-enhanced superconductivity
ResearcherHe built the dark cavity — a resonator that contains no light, only reshaped vacuum — and measured the superconductor inside it getting stronger.
- Evidence for vacuum-enhanced superconductivity in NbSe2 (2026) — Led the experiment: NbSe2 inside a metallic split-ring terahertz dark cavity, with the critical temperature rising by up to 5.4% in a six-layer device and the enhancement peaking at the cavity resonance.
- Magnetic-field tuning of the Casimir force (2021) — With Zeng - the experiment claiming a magnetic handle on the vacuum force.
- Electrically tunable moire magnetism in twisted double bilayers of chromium triiodide (2023) — Nature Electronics - the mainstream materials work behind the Casimir result.
Guido Zavattini (PVLAS collaboration)
experimental physicist, INFN Ferrara; long-time PVLAS vacuum magnetic birefringence experiment
ResearcherPVLAS chased the other great prediction about the vacuum — that a strong magnetic field makes empty space bend light — and the 25-year write-up is a masterclass in honest precision physics.
- The PVLAS experiment: A 25 year effort to measure vacuum magnetic birefringence (2020) — Physics Reports 871, 1–74 — the complete account of a quarter-century attempt to see the vacuum behave like a birefringent material (arXiv:2005.12913).
- The PVLAS experiment: measuring vacuum magnetic birefringence and dichroism with a birefringent Fabry–Perot cavity (2016) — Eur. Phys. J. C 76, 24 — the apparatus and method (arXiv:1510.08052).
- First results from the new PVLAS apparatus: a new limit on vacuum magnetic birefringence (2014) — Phys. Rev. D 90, 092003 — the headline limit on the vacuum's optical response to a magnetic field (arXiv:1406.6518).
Harold E. (Hal) Puthoff
physicist; president and chief executive of EarthTech International and the Institute for Advanced Studies at Austin
ProponentHe has kept a working laboratory pointed at the quantum vacuum for four decades, and EarthTech's publication record is the longest continuous thread in this subject.
- Inertia as a zero-point-field Lorentz force (1994) — With Haisch and Rueda: the paper that put vacuum-derived inertia into Physical Review A.
- Physics of the zero-point field: implications for inertia, gravitation and mass (1997) — Sets out how far the zero-point field can be pushed as an explanation for mass and gravitation.
- Can the vacuum be engineered for spaceflight applications? Overview of theory and experiments (1998) — The programme statement for treating the vacuum as an engineering medium.
What the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumThe metric, warp drives and wormholesEnergy from the vacuumInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
Hrvoje Nikolić
Zagreb theorist who builds toy models to test whether zero-point energy is physical
CriticNikolić supplies a model small enough to check by hand, which is exactly what the 'is the vacuum energy real?' argument needs — a place where both answers can be computed and compared.
- Is zero-point energy physical? A toy model for Casimir-like effect (2017) — Annals of Physics 383, 181-195; a three-degree-of-freedom model showing the Casimir vacuum is not a photon-free ground state, and arguing the force is best read as van der Waals attraction.
John B. Pendry
Chair in Theoretical Solid State Physics, Imperial College London
ResearcherThe founder of metamaterials also asks whether two surfaces sliding past each other in a vacuum feel friction from nothing at all — and he is still arguing it out in print.
- Stable-to-unstable transition in quantum friction (2024) — Physical Review Research, with Oue and Silveirinha — when vacuum drag stops being a mild damping and goes unstable.
- QED in space–time varying materials (2024) — APL Quantum, with Horsley — quantum electrodynamics in media whose properties change in time, the setting for dynamical Casimir effects.
- Shearing the vacuum – quantum friction (1997) — J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 9, 10301 — the paper that started the modern quantum-friction debate.
Kanu Sinha
theoretical physicist, University of Arizona; engineering of quantum fluctuation phenomena
ResearcherThe word in her grant title is 'engineering' — she works on making vacuum fluctuations do what you want at the nanoscale.
- Engineering Quantum Fluctuation Phenomena in Nanoscale Quantum Optical Systems (2024) — $240,000 each at Arizona and Arizona State: a continuing programme whose explicit aim is to engineer, not merely observe, the effects of vacuum fluctuations.
Kerem Cankoçak
Turkish particle physicist (Istanbul Technical University) filming the CERN Casimir demonstration
ResearcherA CERN experimentalist showing the vacuum-force demonstration CERN itself built for the public – authority plus apparatus.
- CERN Science Gateway Casimir deneyi (sanal parçacıklar) (2026) — 7,375 views; CERN's own public Casimir demonstration, explained in Turkish by a CMS physicist.
Kimball A. Milton
theoretical physicist, University of Oklahoma
EducatorHe writes about zero-point energy for people who want to understand it rather than be sold it — including the negative forces and entropy puzzles that make it interesting.
- The Casimir Effect: Physical Manifestations of Zero-Point Energy (2001) — His most-cited work (1,635 citations on Scholar) and still the clearest book-length statement of what zero-point energy does in the real world.
- The Casimir effect: recent controversies and progress (2004) — A frank review of what the field argues about — useful precisely because it does not paper over disagreements.
- Casimir effect in dielectrics (1978) — Early work with Schwinger and DeRaad, 698 citations on Scholar; the Schwinger-school foundation of modern Casimir theory.
Lilia M. Woods
professor and associate chair of physics, University of South Florida
ResearcherShe wrote the review that connects 'what the vacuum does' to 'what the material is made of' — the bridge a curious reader actually needs.
- Materials perspective on Casimir and van der Waals interactions (2016) — Lead author of the Reviews of Modern Physics survey linking material properties to the strength and sign of the vacuum force (arXiv:1509.03338).
Luis de la Peña
theoretical physicist, Instituto de Física, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México
ResearcherHe spent a career arguing that the quantum weirdness of matter is what a real vacuum field looks like from the inside, and he made the case rigorously enough to publish it as a Springer book.
- The Emerging Quantum: The Physics Behind Quantum Mechanics (2015) — With Cetto and Valdés-Hernández: the fullest modern statement of the zero-point-field account of quantum mechanics.
- The Planck Distribution — a Necessary Consequence of the Fluctuating Zero-Point Field (2014) — Derives the Planck spectrum from the vacuum field rather than assuming it.
- Quantum Theory and Linear Stochastic Electrodynamics (2001) — The programme stated compactly in Foundations of Physics.
What the vacuum isThe unified pictureEnergy from the vacuumInertia and gravity from the vacuum
Marco Casolino
INFN experimental physicist streaming detailed Casimir-effect lectures in Italian
ResearcherRepulsive Casimir geometry is the hinge of every 'engineer the vacuum' argument, and he is the rare communicator who teaches it in Italian at lecture depth.
- Cos'è l'effetto Casimir: Energia di punto zero dal vuoto quantistico (2024) — 7,921 views; part one of a working INFN physicist's Casimir series.
- Dominare il vuoto quantistico: repulsione e attrazione nell'effetto Casimir (2026) — Repulsive Casimir configurations – the part most popular coverage omits.
Martin Claassen
assistant professor of physics, University of Pennsylvania; cavity quantum materials theory
ResearcherAn NSF CAREER award in cavity quantum materials is a sign that shaping the vacuum to change what matter does is now a mainstream research career, not a fringe interest.
- CAREER: Quantum Optics of Correlated Electrons in Cavity Quantum Materials (2026) — $334,132 from September 2026: an NSF CAREER award, meaning the agency is funding a whole early career around engineering matter with cavity vacuum fields.
Masahiro Hotta
theoretical physicist, Particle Theory and Cosmology Group, Tohoku University
ResearcherHe is the physicist who wrote down a concrete, experimentally tested recipe for drawing energy out of the zero-point field, and it has now been run on real hardware twice.
- Quantum Energy Teleportation: An Introductory Review (2011) — The accessible entry point to his protocol for extracting usable energy from the ground state of a quantum field using entanglement plus classical communication.
- Quantum Energy Teleportation (2008) — The founding proposal, showing that measurement at one point plus a classical message lets a distant party draw energy out of the zero-point field.
- Exceeding the maximum classical energy density in fully charged quantum batteries (2025) — Recent work extending the same energy-from-correlations idea to quantum battery design.
Mathias Boström
theoretical physicist, Centre of Excellence ENSEMBLE3, Warsaw
ResearcherHe keeps proposing concrete, buildable ways to make the vacuum force do something new — including flipping its sign with a magnetic fluid.
- Prediction of a measurable sign change in the Casimir force using a magnetic fluid (2026) — Phys. Rev. Materials — a concrete, testable recipe for flipping the vacuum force from attraction to repulsion (arXiv:2601.00483).
- High-Temperature Plasma in Casimir Physics (2026) — Extends Casimir theory into plasma conditions (arXiv:2510.26312).
- Casimir forces across magnetic plasmas at nuclear separations (2025) — Annals of Physics 481 — pushes the Casimir framework down to nuclear length scales (arXiv:2505.07860).
Mehran Kardar
professor of physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
ResearcherHe put the Casimir force in its proper company: one of many forces that appear whenever fluctuations are confined, which makes it far less mysterious and far more general.
- Casimir forces between arbitrary compact objects (2007) — Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 170403 with Emig, Graham and Jaffe — an exact scattering method for the vacuum force between any two shapes.
- The 'friction' of vacuum, and other fluctuation-induced forces (1999) — Reviews of Modern Physics with Golestanian — the paper that framed Casimir forces as one member of a whole family of fluctuation effects.
Michael A. Sentef
theoretical physicist, University of Bremen; cavity quantum materials
ResearcherHe is one of the theorists who named and mapped 'cavity quantum materials', the discipline of designing matter by designing the vacuum it sits in.
- Cavity-enhanced superconducting response in an underdoped cuprate (2026) — Co-author on the theory that cavity engineering strengthens phase stiffness in a superconductor.
- Fluctuation engineering in cavity quantum materials (2026) — States the programme plainly: tailored vacuum and thermal spectra can shift a material's phase boundaries.
- Cavity Quantum Materials (2021) — The review that named the field of engineering matter through strong coupling to a cavity's vacuum.
Michael Bordag
theoretical physicist, Leipzig University
ResearcherHe is the field's librarian and organiser — the person whose book and workshops made Casimir physics into a coherent discipline rather than scattered papers.
- Advances in the Casimir Effect (2009) — Lead author of the Oxford monograph distilled from hundreds of Casimir papers — the field's standard sourcebook.
- New developments in the Casimir effect (2001) — Physics Reports review with Mohideen and Mostepanenko; listed at 2,032 citations on Mohideen's Scholar profile.
- The Casimir effect as scattering problem (2007) — Reframes Casimir energy in the scattering language the whole modern field now uses.
Michael Ibison
physicist, Institute for Advanced Studies at Austin / EarthTech International
ResearcherOne of the few people who does SED theory and then designs a bench test of it in the same building.
- Electrodynamics in the zero-point field: on the equilibrium spectral energy distribution and the origin of inertial mass (2001) — An electromagnetic account of inertial mass built strictly inside SED.
- Investigation of the Effect of Casimir Cavities on the Decay Rates of Radioactive Isotopes (2010) — An EarthTech experiment testing whether suppressing vacuum modes changes nuclear behaviour.
Nayeli A. Rodríguez-Briones
quantum information physicist, University of California Berkeley
ResearcherShe led the first bench experiment showing that a state which looks completely drained of energy can still be made to give some up, once you hold the right information about it.
- Experimental Activation of Strong Local Passive States with Quantum Information (2023) — The first physical realisation of energy teleportation, using nuclear magnetic resonance on trans-crotonic acid, published in Physical Review Letters.
- Fundamental Limitations to Local Energy Extraction in Quantum Systems (2019) — Sets the rigorous bound on how much energy you can pull out of a quantum system locally - the honest ceiling on 'energy from the vacuum'.
Noah M. Graham
professor of physics, Middlebury College; quantum and thermal fluctuation energies
ResearcherHe teaches the actual calculation of vacuum energy to undergraduates, which makes his papers unusually readable for someone learning the subject.
- RUI: Quantum and Thermal Fluctuations in Monopoles, Spacetime, and Materials (2022) — $135,000 from August 2022; an NSF Research in Undergraduate Institutions grant, meaning students learn to compute vacuum energies directly.
Owen D. Miller
professor of applied physics and of physics, Yale University
ResearcherHe asks the question that matters most for any 'energy from the vacuum' claim — what is the absolute upper limit? — and derives it rigorously.
- Shape-independent limits to near-field radiative heat transfer (2015) — Sets a ceiling on how strong near-field fluctuation effects can possibly be, whatever you build.
- Fundamental Limits to Near-Field Optical Response over Any Bandwidth (2019) — Phys. Rev. X — the bounds framework that also constrains fluctuational (Casimir-type) interactions.
- Fundamental limits in photonics and electromagnetics: a tutorial (2026) — Tutorial with Francesco Monticone on how to ask 'how good could this possibly get?' in wave physics.
Per Delsing
professor of quantum technology, Chalmers University of Technology
ResearcherHis Chalmers laboratory built the circuit in which the vacuum was first made to radiate, and it remains one of the few places on earth with that capability.
- Observation of the Dynamical Casimir Effect in a Superconducting Circuit (2011) — Senior author on the experiment that produced real photons out of the vacuum in a superconducting transmission line.
Pertti Hakonen
professor of low-temperature physics, Aalto University
ResearcherHe runs the ultra-cold laboratory where the vacuum's own noise is quiet enough to be measured directly, which is the precondition for every experiment in this chapter.
- Dynamical Casimir effect in a Josephson metamaterial (2013) — Senior author on the Aalto demonstration of vacuum photon creation at 5.4 GHz.
- Bipartite entanglement under frequency comb pumping in parametric Josephson circuits (2025) — Parametric Josephson circuits are the same hardware family that produced the first dynamical Casimir observations.
- Observing the Poisson Distribution of a Coherent Microwave Field With a Parametric Photon Detector (2024) — Single-microwave-photon counting is what makes vacuum-photon experiments possible at all.
What the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuumThe vacuum as a quantum fluid
Qing-Dong Jiang
T. D. Lee Fellow and theoretical physicist, Tsung-Dao Lee Institute, Shanghai Jiao Tong University
ResearcherHe is the theorist turning the quantum vacuum into something with adjustable settings — repulsive, enhanced, tunable, switchable — and he supplied the theory for the 2026 vacuum-superconductivity result.
- Chiral Casimir Forces: Repulsive, Enhanced, Tunable (2019) — With Frank Wilczek, found the loophole in the no-go theorem that had made repulsive Casimir forces seem impossible — a prerequisite for any Casimir machine.
- Axial Casimir force (2019) — Extends the vacuum force catalogue to axial couplings, widening the design space for engineered vacuum forces.
- Quantum atmospherics for materials diagnosis (2019) — Proposes reading a material's hidden order from the 'quantum atmosphere' of vacuum fluctuations it projects into the space around it.
What the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuumGravity control and superconductors
Ranjan Singh
professor, Nanyang Technological University; terahertz photonics and metamaterials
ResearcherThe terahertz resonator is the actual machine in these experiments, and he is the photonics specialist who makes it work.
- Cavity-enhanced superconductivity in the two-dimensional limit of NbSe2 (2026) — Co-author; the terahertz resonator design is the instrument that shapes the vacuum modes the superconductor feels.
- Active control of electromagnetically induced transparency analogue in terahertz metamaterials (2012) — Nature Communications - actively switching how a structure couples to the electromagnetic field.
- Sharp Fano resonances in THz metamaterials (2011) — The high-quality resonances that make strong vacuum coupling possible at terahertz frequencies.
Raymond Laflamme
professor of physics, University of Waterloo; founding director of the Institute for Quantum Computing
ResearcherHe brought the precision NMR toolkit that turned a vacuum-energy thought experiment into a measurement with error bars.
- Experimental Activation of Strong Local Passive States with Quantum Information (2023) — Senior author on the NMR demonstration that information can unlock energy from an apparently exhausted state.
- Perfect Quantum Error Correcting Code (1996) — The five-qubit code - foundational quantum information.
- Black strings and p-branes are unstable (1993) — With Gregory - the Gregory-Laflamme instability, a standard result in the gravity side of this field.
What the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuumThe metric, warp drives and wormholes
Ricardo S. Decca
experimental physicist and department chair, Indiana University Indianapolis
ResearcherHis micro-oscillator measurements are the sharpest ruler the field has for asking whether anything beyond the known vacuum force is hiding at sub-micron distances.
- Tests of new physics from precise measurements of the Casimir pressure between two gold-coated plates (2007) — His most-cited paper: micro-torsional-oscillator Casimir pressure used to bound extra dimensions and new forces (arXiv:hep-ph/0703290).
- Novel constraints on light elementary particles and extra-dimensional physics from the Casimir effect (2007) — Shows how a benchtop vacuum-force measurement becomes a particle-physics constraint.
- Capacitance measurements and electrostatic calibrations in experiments measuring the Casimir force (2009) — The calibration methodology that decides whether a Casimir measurement is trustworthy.
Roberto Onofrio
professor of physics and astronomy, Dartmouth College (previously University of Padua)
ResearcherHe connects the Casimir force to the biggest open question a reader will have: does the vacuum tell us anything new about gravity at short distances?
- Measurement of the Casimir force between parallel metallic surfaces (2002) — With Bressi, Carugno and Ruoso — the rare experiment that used Casimir's own flat parallel-plate geometry (arXiv:quant-ph/0203002).
- Casimir forces and non-Newtonian gravitation (2006) — New Journal of Physics: how Casimir measurements bound deviations from Newtonian gravity at short range.
- Towards a precision measurement of the Casimir force in a cylinder-plane geometry (2005) — With Dalvit and Mazzitelli — a geometry chosen to expose thermal Casimir effects and the limits of the usual approximation.
Salvatore Savasta
theoretical physicist, University of Messina; ultrastrong light-matter coupling and vacuum radiation
ResearcherHe works on the regime where light and matter couple so strongly that the ground state is already full of virtual photons waiting to be released.
- Quantum Vacuum Radiation Near a Critical Point (2026) — Non-adiabatic modulation through a critical point converts virtual excitations into real photons — a lower-threshold cousin of the dynamical Casimir effect.
- Circuit QED spectra in the ultrastrong coupling regime: How they differ from cavity QED (2024) — Ultrastrong coupling is the regime where vacuum photons stop being bookkeeping and start being measurable.
- Quantum phase transitions in many-dipole light-matter systems (2022) — Superradiant phase transitions are the mainstream version of 'the vacuum can change state'.
Serge Reynaud
emeritus CNRS researcher, Laboratoire Kastler Brossel, Sorbonne Université
ResearcherHis LKB page states the theme plainly — Casimir forces and vacuum fluctuations, alongside gravity and quantum physics — and his scattering framework is how most people now calculate the effect.
- The Casimir effect within scattering theory (2006) — With Lambrecht and Maia Neto — the scattering formulation that made arbitrary geometries and real materials computable.
- Casimir force and the quantum theory of lossy optical cavities (2003) — Treats the two mirrors and the gap as a quantum optical network — a clean way to see where the force comes from.
- Casimir forces (2015) — An accessible overview of the effect, its theory and its experiments.
Stefan Scheel
theoretical quantum optician, University of Rostock
ResearcherMacroscopic QED is the language in which the Casimir effect stops being a special case and becomes ordinary quantum optics in real materials — and he helped write it.
- Macroscopic quantum electrodynamics and duality (2009) — Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 140404 with Buhmann — an electric-magnetic duality that constrains Casimir and Casimir-Polder forces (arXiv:0806.2211).
- Macroscopic quantum electrodynamics in nonlocal and nonreciprocal media (2012) — New J. Phys. 14, 083034 — extends the framework to exotic media where the usual assumptions fail (arXiv:1109.6193).
Steve K. Lamoreaux
experimental physicist, Yale University (Wright Lab)
ResearcherHe is the person who turned 'the vacuum pushes on mirrors' from a chalkboard result into a measured force, and he still runs the tabletop lab where those measurements get sharper.
- Demonstration of the Casimir Force in the 0.6 to 6 μm Range (1997) — The torsion-pendulum experiment that reopened Casimir measurement as a modern precision science.
- The Casimir force: background, experiments, and applications (2005) — The standard entry-point review for anyone who wants the whole experimental landscape in one place.
- Observation of the thermal Casimir force (2011) — First reported observation of the temperature-dependent (thermal) part of the Casimir force, with Sushkov, Kim and Dalvit.
Thomas G. Philbin
theoretical physicist, University of Exeter
ResearcherHe is the careful voice on quantum friction and vacuum states — the person who checks whether an exciting vacuum effect survives a rigorous calculation.
- Casimir-Lifshitz force between moving plates at different temperatures (2009) — With Ulf Leonhardt — finds a lateral force from thermal radiation but no quantum-vacuum friction between the plates.
- Damped vacuum states of light (2016) — J. Opt. 18, 095201 — what the vacuum state actually looks like in a lossy medium (arXiv:1603.00233).
- Reflection and transmission in nonlocal susceptibility models with multiple resonances (2017) — The material response that any honest Casimir calculation depends on (arXiv:1702.05058).
Thomas W. Ebbesen
professor, University of Strasbourg; founder of vibrational strong coupling and polaritonic chemistry
ResearcherHe proved, years before the 2026 superconductivity results, that simply coupling molecules to the electromagnetic vacuum of a cavity changes how they behave and react.
- Exploring Superconductivity under Strong Coupling with the Vacuum Electromagnetic Field (2019) — Reported Rb3C60's superconducting transition rising from 30 K to 45 K at ordinary pressure under vibrational strong coupling, with a clear Meissner effect — an early and striking vacuum-field result.
Thorsten Emig
CNRS research director; fluctuation-induced interactions and Casimir physics
ResearcherIf you have ever wondered whether the vacuum force could be cancelled or steered by shaping objects, he is the theorist who was funded to find out.
- Casimir forces between arbitrary compact objects (2007) — Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 170403 — first author on the exact multipole/scattering method for any pair of shapes.
- Surface scattering expansion of the Casimir-Polder interaction for magneto-dielectric bodies (2023) — With Bimonte — extends the method to rough, magnetic real-world surfaces.
Timothy H. Boyer
professor of physics, City College of New York (professor since 1980); founder of modern stochastic electrodynamics
ResearcherHe is the living founder of the picture in which the vacuum is a real, physical, fluctuating field that things move in — and he was still publishing it in 2026.
- Random electrodynamics: The theory of classical electrodynamics with classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation (1975) — The founding paper of stochastic electrodynamics: keep classical physics, add a real random zero-point field, and much of quantum behaviour follows.
- The classical linear oscillator in classical electrodynamics with classical zero-point radiation (2026) — Published in 2026, more than fifty years after his founding paper — evidence the programme is alive, not historical.
- A Brief Survey of Stochastic Electrodynamics (1980) — His own short introduction to the field, still the cleanest way in.
What the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumEnergy from the vacuum
Viktor V. Dodonov
theoretical physicist and the field's historian, University of Brasília
ResearcherIf you read one document to understand how far the science of making photons from nothing has actually come, this open-access review is it.
- Fifty Years of the Dynamical Casimir Effect (2020) — The standard open-access survey of everything achieved in vacuum photon creation across five decades, with emphasis on post-2010 results.
Vladimir M. Mostepanenko
theoretical physicist, Pulkovo Observatory, St Petersburg
ResearcherTogether with Klimchitskaya he wrote most of the theory that experimenters compare their data against — and he is candid about where it does not fit.
- The Casimir force between real materials: Experiment and theory (2009) — The Reviews of Modern Physics account that defined how the field talks about material effects (arXiv:0902.4022).
- Advances in the Casimir Effect (2009) — Co-author of the Oxford reference monograph on the Casimir effect.
- Tests of new physics from precise measurements of the Casimir pressure between two gold-coated plates (2007) — With Decca and collaborators — turning a Casimir measurement into limits on new forces and extra dimensions.
Wayne Cheng-Wei Huang
physicist working on simulations of stochastic electrodynamics
ResearcherHis simulations are the clearest demonstration of the central SED claim — that classical matter in a real vacuum field starts behaving quantum-mechanically.
- Discrete Excitation Spectrum of a Classical Harmonic Oscillator in Zero-Point Radiation (2015) — Shows a classical oscillator in a real vacuum field producing something that looks like quantised energy levels.
- Dynamics Underlying the Gaussian Distribution of the Classical Harmonic Oscillator in Zero-Point Radiation (2013) — Traces exactly how the vacuum field shapes the motion into the quantum ground-state distribution.
- Testing Quantum Coherence in Stochastic Electrodynamics with Squeezed Schrödinger Cat States (2019) — Finds SED does not reproduce double-slit-type interference - the clearest published limit on the theory.
What the vacuum isScalar waves and the field behind the fieldsInertia and gravity from the vacuumEnergy from the vacuum
Weibo Gao
experimental physicist, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore
ResearcherHis group produced the second, independent 2026 measurement of cavity-enhanced superconductivity, and the effect grew stronger the thinner the material got.
- Cavity-enhanced superconductivity in the two-dimensional limit of NbSe2 (2026) — Senior author on the independent confirmation that a terahertz cavity raises NbSe2's transition temperature, with bilayer Tc rising 10% from 3.02 K to 3.41 K at 0.92 THz.
- Polarized and Directional Single-Photon Emission in WSe2 Enhanced by q-BIC Nanoantennae (2025) — Engineering the local photon vacuum to steer emission is the everyday, working version of vacuum engineering.
Zubin Jacob
professor of electrical and computer engineering, Purdue University; vacuum fluctuation engineering in photonics
ResearcherHe designs materials whose whole purpose is to change what the vacuum does inside them, which is the engineering side of the Casimir story.
- Engineering Long-Range Dipole-Dipole Interactions (2016) — $461,877 from December 2016; work on reshaping the vacuum modes that mediate forces between distant atoms.
Baylor University dynamical Casimir group (David Hilton)
NSF EAGER-funded effort to generate entangled light from the dynamical Casimir effect in solid-state devices
ResearcherThe dynamical Casimir effect moving from a one-off Nature result toward a usable light source, with a current NSF grant behind it.
- EAGER: Entangled Light Generation via the Dynamical Casimir Effect (2024) — $150,000 - making real, entangled photons out of the vacuum, funded as high-risk exploratory research.
David Bishop Casimir energy group, Boston University
Group funded to detect the Casimir energy itself rather than only the force it produces
ResearcherIf you want to know whether there is really energy in a Casimir cavity rather than just a force, this is the NSF grant that set out to measure it.
- Detecting the Casimir Energy (2017) — $370,000 - an NSF-funded attempt to measure the vacuum energy stored in a Casimir cavity, which is the quantity a Casimir power chip would have to draw on.
Garret Moddel laboratory, University of Colorado Boulder
University laboratory that lists zero-point energy technology and low-energy nuclear reactions among its declared research interests
ResearcherA named professor emeritus at a major public university listing zero-point energy technology as a research interest on the official department page - hard to argue with, and easy for a reader to check.
- Research interests: Zero-Point Energy Technology; Low Energy Nuclear Reactions (2026) — Listed openly on a US university faculty page - among the plainest institutional acknowledgements of this research area anywhere.
- Optical rectenna and geometric diode work (2024) — The same tunnelling-device physics that Casimir power-chip proposals depend on.
What the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuumLattice confinement fusion
Instituto de Física Teórica IFT (UAM–CSIC)
Spanish national theoretical-physics institute; public lectures on vacuum energy and the Casimir effect
EducatorAn actual national physics institute explaining vacuum energy in Spanish – the credibility anchor for the Spanish-language chapter two.
- La energía del VACÍO | Efecto Casimir (2018) — 50,313 views; institutional Spanish treatment of vacuum energy and the Casimir force.
Jeremy Munday Casimir laboratory, UC Davis
Laboratory measuring the Casimir torque and vacuum-fluctuation-induced torques on liquid crystals
ResearcherMunday's group measures a twisting force produced by empty space, which is a far harder and more surprising measurement than the ordinary Casimir attraction.
- Controlling the Casimir Torque (2020) — $156,467 at UC Davis, following NSF 1806768 ($240,000) at Maryland.
- Vacuum Fluctuation Induced Torque on Liquid Crystal Molecules (2015) — $279,306 - the vacuum twisting matter, funded by name.
Kimball Milton vacuum energy group, University of Oklahoma
Theory group working on Casimir-Polder interactions and quantum field theory under external conditions
ResearcherMilton is the person who keeps the vacuum-energy calculations honest, and NSF has funded that work - and its conference series - for two decades.
- Advances in Casimir-Polder Interactions between Atoms and Substrates (2020) — $240,000 - continuing NSF support for pure Casimir theory.
- Quantum Field Theory Under the Influence of External Conditions (2009) — NSF support for the QFEXT conference series, which is the field's main theory meeting.
- Collaborative Research: Quantum Vacuum Energy (2006) — With Stephen Fulling at Texas A&M (NSF 0554849, $270,701).
Lilia Woods quantum friction group, University of South Florida
Theory group on quantum friction - the drag a moving object feels from the quantum vacuum itself
ResearcherQuantum friction is chapter three's question asked in a form that condensed-matter physics already knows how to fund and calculate.
- Quantum Kinetics for Quantum Friction: a Materials Perspective (2023) — $200,000 - NSF funding the question of whether empty space resists motion, which is the direct neighbour of the vacuum-inertia idea.
Luis de la Peña and Ana María Cetto
physicists, Instituto de Física, UNAM; the Mexico City stochastic-electrodynamics school
ResearcherThe strongest academic case that the quantum vacuum is a real physical medium rather than a bookkeeping device - which is the premise the whole site rests on.
- The Emerging Quantum: The Physics Behind Quantum Mechanics (2015) — Derives quantisation as an emergent property of matter in permanent contact with the zero-point field.
- The Quantum Dice: An Introduction to Stochastic Electrodynamics (1996) — The standard textbook treatment of SED before the newer synthesis.
- Completing the Quantum Ontology with the Electromagnetic Zero-Point Field (2024) — Their current statement of why the vacuum field belongs in the ontology, not just the maths.
What the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumThe unified picture
Max Planck Institute for the Structure and Dynamics of Matter (MPSD)
research institute where cavity and vacuum-field control of materials is a central programme
ResearcherOne institute holds both the experimental and theoretical halves of vacuum-field materials engineering, so its output is the single best feed to follow for this chapter.
- Cavity-enhanced superconductivity in the two-dimensional limit of NbSe2 (2026) — MPSD theory (Rubio group) underpins one of the two independent 2026 cavity-superconductivity results.
- Cavity and Floquet engineering of quantum materials (2026) — Research groups here produced much of the light-induced superconductivity and cavity-controlled-matter literature.
What the vacuum isGravity control and superconductorsEnergy from the vacuum
Ricardo Decca precision gravity laboratory, Indiana University
Laboratory testing Newtonian gravity at submicron scales, where the Casimir force is the dominant background
ResearcherA good reminder of how central the Casimir force has become: you now have to model the vacuum accurately before you can even test gravity.
- Precision experimental tests of Newtonian gravity at the submicron scale (2007) — $300,000 - at these distances you cannot test gravity at all without first understanding the Casimir force precisely.
Umar Mohideen precision Casimir laboratory, UC Riverside
Distinguished professor's laboratory performing the world's most precise Casimir force measurements, including on graphene
ResearcherThirty years of continuously NSF-funded precision measurement of a force that comes out of empty space - the experimental bedrock everything else in this chapter rests on.
- Demonstration of an Unusual Thermal Effect in the Casimir Force from Graphene (2021) — A measured thermal Casimir effect where the theory had been disputed for years.
- Difference Casimir Force Precision Measurements To Probe Long Wavelength Behavior (2020) — $548,768 from NSF - one of a continuous chain of Casimir grants to this lab going back to 2006.
UnLAB LLC
Savannah company developing 'fluctuation flow' propulsion - rectifying vacuum fluctuations into directed thrust with asymmetric nanostructures
CompanyA model of how this work should be reported - the outcomes report says plainly that the first measurement was swamped by residual stress and describes the better method they built next.
- SBIR Phase I: Fluctuation Flow Propulsion (2024) — Nano-layered metal/dielectric stacks on cantilevers measured by white-light interferometry; residual stress masked the sought force, so the team moved to diamagnetic levitation to reach picoNewton sensitivity.
What the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuumInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
USTC vacuum-superconductivity group (Zeng & Cheng)
the experimental group that first demonstrated vacuum-fluctuation-enhanced superconductivity
ResearcherThis is the group that moved the vacuum from theory to instrument — they changed nothing but the shape of empty space around a superconductor, and the superconductor improved.
- Evidence for vacuum-enhanced superconductivity in NbSe2 (2026) — Published in Nature on 19 August 2026: a van der Waals superconductor in a metallic split-ring terahertz dark cavity, with critical temperature, critical current and critical field all rising, and the enhancement peaking at the cavity's resonant frequency.
- Magnetic-field tuning of the Casimir force (2021) — The claim: an applied magnetic field measurably changes the Casimir force.
- Reply to: Re-examining magnetic tuning of Casimir forces (2023) — The published defence - the argument is still open, which is the honest state of it.
What the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuumGravity control and superconductors
Wallenberg Centre for Quantum Technology (WACQT), Chalmers
A twelve-year, one-billion-krona Swedish national quantum programme, home to the group that first observed the dynamical Casimir effect
ResearcherWorth knowing that the dynamical Casimir experiment came out of a billion-krona national quantum-computing programme, not a fringe lab.
- Wallenberg Centre for Quantum Technology (2026) — SEK 1 billion over twelve years - the funding scale behind the hardware that makes vacuum-photon experiments routine.
Wilczek Quantum Center / T. D. Lee Institute
theory centre at Shanghai Jiao Tong University where the chiral-Casimir and vacuum-superconductivity theory is produced
ResearcherA named centre where the deliberate engineering of vacuum forces is the research programme rather than a side interest.
- Evidence for vacuum-enhanced superconductivity in NbSe2 (2026) — The theory for the first vacuum-enhanced superconductor came from this centre, jointly with Frank Wilczek.
What the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuumGravity control and superconductors
Woo-Joong Kim torsion balance laboratory, Seattle University
Undergraduate-institution laboratory doing precision Casimir force measurements and searches for non-Newtonian gravity
ResearcherProof that this is not big-machine physics: a small undergraduate university has been running NSF-funded Casimir and short-range-gravity experiments for over a decade.
- RUI: Search for Non-Newtonian Gravity Using A High-Sensitivity Torsion Balance (2021) — $149,999, following NSF 1806680 ($150,000) and NSF 1307150 ($90,000).
04 · Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineering
Alejandro W. Rodriguez
professor of electrical and computer engineering, Princeton University
ResearcherHe turned Casimir physics into a design problem: tell the computer what force you want, and it tells you what shape to build.
- Casimir forces in the time domain: Theory (2009) — With McCauley, Joannopoulos and Johnson — the FDTD algorithm that let anyone compute Casimir forces in arbitrary geometries (arXiv:0904.0267).
- The Casimir effect in microstructured geometries (2011) — Nature Photonics review with Capasso and Johnson on designing the vacuum force through geometry.
- Measurement of non-monotonic Casimir forces between silicon nanostructures (2017) — Co-author on the HKUST experiment his group's theory predicted (arXiv:1701.02351).
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuum
Benjamin Spreng
Casimir theorist in the Munday Lab, UC Davis
ResearcherHe is doing the careful theory behind the headline Casimir-torque and repulsion experiments — the quiet half of how those results get believed.
- Thermal Effects in the Casimir Torque between Birefringent Plates (2025) — Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 013602 — first author on the thermal theory of the Casimir torque.
- Enhanced repulsive Casimir forces between gold and thin magnetodielectric plates (2023) — Shows how magnetic response can be engineered to push, not pull.
- Recent developments on the Casimir torque (2022) — Compact review of the twisting side of the vacuum force.
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum is
Bernard Haisch
astrophysicist; director of the Calphysics Institute; co-inventor of the quantum vacuum energy extraction patent
ProponentHe is the bridge between the two halves of this chapter — the theory that mass itself comes from the vacuum, and the patent that tries to draw power from it.
- Inertia as a zero-point-field Lorentz force (1994) — With Alfonso Rueda and Harold Puthoff: the proposal that inertia is a reaction force from the zero-point field rather than an intrinsic property of matter.
- Physics of the zero-point field: implications for inertia, gravitation and mass (1997) — The fuller statement of the programme connecting vacuum energy to mass and gravity.
- Quantum vacuum energy extraction (2008) — With Garret Moddel: the Casimir-cavity power-conversion patent, filed 2005 and granted 2008.
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumEnergy from the vacuum
Diego A. R. Dalvit
theoretical physicist, Theoretical Division, Los Alamos National Laboratory
ResearcherHe sits between theory and experiment — the person co-authoring both the big reviews and the measurements they explain.
- Materials perspective on Casimir and van der Waals interactions (2016) — Reviews of Modern Physics with Woods, Tkatchenko, Rodriguez-Lopez, Rodriguez and Podgornik — the materials-eye view of the vacuum force (arXiv:1509.03338).
- Observation of the thermal Casimir force (2011) — Co-author on the Nature Physics measurement of the temperature-dependent Casimir force.
- Casimir Physics (2011) — Edited Springer Lecture Notes in Physics volume (372 citations on Scholar) that collects the modern methods in one place.
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum is
Fabrizio Pinto
physicist working on Casimir force actuation and vacuum-force engineering
ResearcherHe has spent his career on the practical question the rest of the field skirts: how do you get the Casimir force to do mechanical work on demand?
- Membrane actuation by Casimir force manipulation (2008) — Works out how to move a real mechanical membrane using the Casimir force — a concrete step from vacuum energy to mechanical work.
- Casimir forces in relativistic metrology: Fundamental physical tests and aerospace applications (2016) — Sets out what a spacecraft engineer would actually need from Casimir physics.
- The Casimir effect and its role in nanotechnology applications (2018) — A survey of where vacuum forces already matter in real devices.
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuumInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
Federico Capasso
applied physicist, Harvard University
ResearcherHe is the applied physicist who kept asking what you can build with the vacuum force — a moving micromachine, then a repulsive force — and then went and built it.
- Quantum Mechanical Actuation of Microelectromechanical Systems by the Casimir Force (2001) — Science paper (with Chan, Aksyuk, Kleiman, Bishop) that made a micromachine move using nothing but vacuum fluctuations.
- Measured long-range repulsive Casimir–Lifshitz forces (2009) — Nature paper with Munday and Parsegian: the first measurement of a Casimir force that pushes apart instead of pulling together.
- The Casimir effect in microstructured geometries (2011) — Nature Photonics review with Rodriguez and Johnson on shaping the vacuum force by shaping the surfaces.
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuum
G. Jordan Maclay
physicist; founder and director of Quantum Fields LLC; Casimir-effect theorist and MEMS designer
ResearcherHe wrote both the classic calculation that made Casimir energy respectable and the engineering papers on how cavity geometry lets you steer it.
- Vacuum stress between conducting plates: an image solution (1969) — Written with his doctoral adviser Lowell Brown, this is the calculation that reframed the Casimir effect in modern quantum field theory terms, and it is still cited constantly.
- Unusual properties of conductive rectangular cavities in the zero point electromagnetic field (1999) — Shows that changing a Casimir cavity's shape changes the sign and size of the vacuum energy inside it, which is the design principle every Casimir device depends on.
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuum
Garret Moddel
professor emeritus of electrical, computer and energy engineering, University of Colorado Boulder
ResearcherA tenured engineering professor at a major university who lists zero-point energy conversion as an official research area and holds the foundational patent, which is the clearest sign that this is an engineering question and not only a philosophical one.
- Quantum vacuum energy extraction (2008) — With Bernard Haisch: suppressing vacuum energy at chosen frequencies inside Casimir cavities so that electron energy-level changes release extractable power; filed 2005, granted 2008, now assigned to the Regents of the University of Colorado.
- Extraction of Zero-Point Energy from the Vacuum: Assessment of Stochastic Electrodynamics-Based Approach as Compared to Other Methods (2009) — With Dmitriyeva; separates the proposed extraction routes and shows which ones violate thermodynamics and which do not.
- Quantum vacuum energy extraction (patent) (2008) — The device concept behind the Casimir-cavity approach he assessed.
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuum
Harold G. "Sonny" White
physicist and engineer; principal investigator, Casimir, Inc.; director of advanced research, Limitless Space Institute
ProponentHe is the working engineer who moved from thinking about the vacuum to fabricating cavities meant to draw power from it, with public funding and a public deliverable.
- SBIR Phase I: Development of devices to manipulate the structure of quantum field energy for use in electric power generation (2024) — The federally funded project in which he sets out to turn Casimir cavities into continuous electrical power cells.
- Worldline numerics applied to custom Casimir geometry generates unanticipated intersection with Alcubierre warp metric (2021) — The DARPA-funded Casimir-cavity study in which a micro-scale energy density distribution was reported to resemble a warp metric.
- Warp Field Mechanics 101 (2011) — His NASA technical presentation of the warp-field concept and the interferometer test he proposed for it.
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum isThe metric, warp drives and wormholesEnergy from the vacuumInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
Ho Bun Chan
experimental physicist, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology
ResearcherHe shows the vacuum force is engineerable: carve the silicon differently and the force between two chips behaves in a way flat plates never could.
- Quantum Mechanical Actuation of Microelectromechanical Systems by the Casimir Force (2001) — As lead author with Capasso's group: the vacuum force made to drive a real micromechanical device.
- Measurement of non-monotonic Casimir forces between silicon nanostructures (2017) — Nature Photonics: nanostructured silicon makes the Casimir force change slope with distance — geometry, not just material, reshapes the vacuum (arXiv:1701.02351).
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuum
Jeremy N. Munday
professor of electrical and computer engineering, UC Davis; leads the Munday Lab
ResearcherHis lab is the place to watch if you want the vacuum force turned into a control knob — repulsive, switchable, twistable — rather than a nuisance that sticks nanomachines together.
- Measured long-range repulsive Casimir–Lifshitz forces (2009) — With Capasso and Parsegian — the first measurement of a repulsive Casimir force, in fluid.
- Casimir Force Control Enabled by 3D Nanostructures (2025) — Nano Letters: dramatic tuning of the vacuum force using 3D nanostructures, with no liquid and no exotic materials.
- Thermal Effects in the Casimir Torque between Birefringent Plates (2025) — Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 013602 — the vacuum can twist as well as pull, and temperature changes the twist.
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuum
Paul M. Thibado
professor of physics, University of Arkansas; graphene fluctuation energy harvesting
ResearcherHis graphene work is the most careful published attempt to draw usable current from ambient fluctuations, and it is worth understanding precisely because it is thermal rather than vacuum energy — it shows what a rigorous version of this claim looks like.
- Fluctuation-induced current from freestanding graphene (2020) — The central result: the spontaneous rippling of freestanding graphene drives a measurable current through a circuit, without violating thermodynamics.
- Graphene ripples as a realization of a two-dimensional Ising model: a scanning tunneling microscope study (2015) — The microscopy that first characterised the ripples he later turned into a power source.
- Spectrum Analysis of Thermally Driven Curvature Inversion in Strained Graphene Ripples for Energy Conversion Applications (2025) — Shows the programme is still active and still being refined a decade on.
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuum
Richard A. Norte
experimental physicist, nanomechanics and Casimir microchips (TU Delft)
ResearcherHis microchip platform is the new hardware that could finally test whether superconductivity changes the vacuum force — a question open since the 1960s.
- High-resolution Casimir force sensing across a superconducting transition (2025) — Suspended nanoscale plates with area-to-separation ratios three orders of magnitude beyond prior work, read out by scanning tunnelling microscopy.
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum is
Stefan Yoshi Buhmann
theoretical physicist, macroscopic QED and dispersion forces
ResearcherHe works on the general theory behind every version of the vacuum force — atoms, surfaces, moving bodies — and is now involved in experiments that isolate the vacuum's own contribution.
- Experimentally separating vacuum fluctuations from source radiation (2026) — Nature Communications with Herter, Lindel, Gabriel and Faist — separates what the vacuum does from what the source emits (arXiv:2502.18208).
- Self-assembly of metallic MEMS using Casimir forces (2025) — Uses the vacuum force as an assembly tool rather than a nuisance.
- Macroscopic quantum electrodynamics and duality (2009) — Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 140404 with Stefan Scheel — a symmetry that constrains all dispersion forces (arXiv:0806.2211).
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum is
Steven G. Johnson
professor of applied mathematics (and physics), Massachusetts Institute of Technology
ResearcherBecause of him you do not need a torsion balance to explore the Casimir force — you can simulate it in free software on a laptop.
- Numerical methods for computing Casimir interactions (2011) — Casimir Physics, Lecture Notes in Physics 834, ch. 6 — the review that made computing vacuum forces a standard engineering task.
- Casimir forces in the time domain: Theory (2009) — The algorithm behind Meep's Casimir solver, with Rodriguez, McCauley and Joannopoulos.
- The Casimir effect in microstructured geometries (2011) — Nature Photonics review with Rodriguez and Capasso.
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum is
Umar Mohideen
experimental physicist, University of California, Riverside
ResearcherIf you want to know what the Casimir force actually measures — not what it is supposed to be — his experiments and his monograph are where the numbers come from.
- Precision Measurement of the Casimir Force from 0.1 to 0.9 μm (1998) — The atomic-force-microscope measurement that gave the Casimir force percent-level precision (arXiv:physics/9805038).
- New developments in the Casimir effect (2001) — Physics Reports review with Bordag and Mostepanenko — his most-cited paper (2,032 citations on his Scholar profile).
- The Casimir force between real materials: Experiment and theory (2009) — Reviews of Modern Physics survey of how real metals, not ideal mirrors, shape the measured force (arXiv:0902.4022).
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum is
Casimir, Inc.
Houston, Texas startup developing Casimir-cavity power cells, funded by an NSF SBIR Phase I award
CompanyThis is what it looks like when vacuum-energy conversion is taken seriously by a national funding agency: a named company, a named investigator, a dollar figure and a deliverable you can look up.
- SBIR Phase I: Development of devices to manipulate the structure of quantum field energy for use in electric power generation (2024) — $274,920, 1 May to 30 November 2024, PI Harold White: Casimir cavities augmented with electrically connected conducting pillars, with the objective of predicting tunnelling current across metal-insulator-metal stacks and fabricating prototype cells.
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuum
Quantum Fields LLC
small research and development company working on Casimir forces, vacuum energy and MEMS
CompanyA company founded expressly to work on Casimir forces and vacuum energy, whose publication list is a compact reading course in the subject.
- Quantum Fields LLC publication list (2026) — A working catalogue of Casimir-effect and vacuum-energy papers from a company set up specifically to pursue them.
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuum
UnLAB (UNLAB LLC)
non-profit research organisation in Savannah, Georgia working on vacuum-fluctuation propulsion
CompanyTheir honest published sequence — first measurement defeated by stray stress, then a better instrument built to reach piconewtons — is a model of how this kind of claim should be tested.
- SBIR Phase I: Fluctuation Flow Propulsion (2024) — $275,000, 15 August 2024 to 30 November 2025: asymmetric nanostructures such as resonant tunnelling diodes on cantilever beams, with a diamagnetic-levitation measurement built to resolve piconewton forces after residual stress swamped the interferometric attempt.
Casimir physics and vacuum-force engineeringWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuum
06 · The vacuum at cosmic scale
Ali Kaya
Cosmologist who wrote the newest teaching-level derivation of the cosmological constant problem
EducatorThis is the 2026 paper to hand a student: it does the vacuum-energy calculation three different ways, in the open, so the reader can see exactly where the famous mismatch comes from and how big it honestly is.
- The Cosmological Constant Problem: An Accessible Introduction (2026) — With Adam Lahey; accepted by the American Journal of Physics. Works the vacuum energy of a massive scalar field in flat space and in an expanding universe, with dimensional, cutoff and adiabatic regularisation shown in full, and notes that the famous 120-order-of-magnitude figure does not account for renormalisation.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuum
Antonio (Tony) Padilla
Nottingham cosmologist behind vacuum energy sequestering, and one of physics' best-known public explainers of the problem
ProponentPadilla is the rare theorist who both proposes a concrete mechanism for hiding vacuum energy from gravity and can explain the whole puzzle to a general audience in twelve minutes on YouTube.
- Lectures on the Cosmological Constant Problem (2015) — 31-page graduate lectures covering radiative instability, Weinberg's no-go theorem, and the sequestering proposal.
- Sequestering the Standard Model Vacuum Energy (2014) — With Nemanja Kaloper; Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 091304 — a reformulation of general relativity in which Standard Model vacuum energy, loops included, never sources spacetime curvature.
- The Cosmological Constant Problem (and its sequester) (2015) — Perimeter Institute seminar, 10 April 2015, calling it 'the worst fine tuning problem in Physics'.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumThe unified picture
Barry Setterfield
Independent researcher; author of the varying-zero-point-density cosmology in which the speed of light falls as the vacuum's energy density rises
ProponentThe site already builds on his argument that Planck's constant measures the zero-point field's density, and it reached the corpus through Douglas Miller rather than from him. Citing the argument and omitting its author would be dishonest. State the provenance plainly at the same time: Setterfield is a creationist, his site is titled Genesis Science Research, and a young-universe reading of Genesis is his stated motivation for the varying-light-speed idea. Neither fact settles the physics, which is assessable on its own terms by the test Miller names against himself - a measurement that separates Planck's constant from the fine-structure constant.
- Cosmology and the Zero Point Energy (2013) — The monograph the site's varying-zero-point-density material comes from. Goodreads lists Setterfield alone; the corpus cites it with Daniel Dzimano - confirm the co-authorship before printing it.
- The zero point energy and the constants of nature — The argument the site uses via Douglas Miller: the vacuum's density sets permittivity and permeability, therefore the speed of light, with the fine-structure constant invariant because its terms move together.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumThe vacuum as a quantum fluid
Brian Keating
Chancellor's Distinguished Professor of Physics, UC San Diego; principal investigator of the Simons Observatory; author and podcast host
EducatorOne of the working cosmologists the channel most wants to engage, and a fair, accurate entry for him is the site's answer to a mocking register it does not use. He runs an actual instrument pointed at the oldest light in the universe, which is where a claim about the vacuum's energy density has to end up being settled.
- Losing the Nobel Prize (2018) — An insider account of how cosmology's incentives shape which results get announced - the same sociology this site describes from outside.
- Into the Impossible (2020) — Long-form interviews with cosmologists and Nobel laureates; the venue where the mainstream case on dark energy is argued at length.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isThe vacuum as a quantum fluid
Cliff P. Burgess
Effective-field-theory specialist who explains precisely why it is so hard to get dark energy out of micro-physics
ResearcherBurgess gives you the referee's rulebook: read him and you can tell for yourself whether a new claim about vacuum energy actually solves anything.
- The Cosmological Constant Problem: Why it's hard to get Dark Energy from Micro-physics (2013) — 52 pages of Les Houches lectures that define naturalness carefully and set out the criteria any proposed solution has to meet.
- Yoga Dark Energy: Natural Relaxation and Other Dark Implications of a Supersymmetric Gravity Sector (2022) — With Danielle Dineen and Fernando Quevedo; JCAP — a framework in which the gravitational response of heavy-particle vacuum energies is strongly suppressed.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumThe unified picture
Daniel Whiteson
Professor of physics and astronomy, University of California, Irvine; particle physicist on ATLAS at CERN, author and podcast host
EducatorThe clearest mainstream statement of the dark-energy picture this site has to be able to answer accurately, from a working particle physicist who explains it for a living. The site's rule is that his position is stated at full strength and without an adjective; the directory is where it gets stated fairly.
- We Have No Idea (2017) — A popular account of what physics does not know, which is the honest version of the argument the site makes from the other side.
- Daniel and Kelly's Extraordinary Universe (2026) — The podcast where his account of dark energy - constant density as space expands, unlike matter, which dilutes - is stated most plainly.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isThe vacuum as a quantum fluid
Emilio Elizalde
Barcelona theorist who supplies the mathematics (zeta regularisation) used to make vacuum energy finite
ResearcherEvery claim about 'how much energy the vacuum carries' depends on a choice of regularisation, and Elizalde is the person who has spent a career making that choice rigorous rather than hand-waved.
- Zeta Functions and the Cosmos - A Basic Brief Review (2021) — Universe 7(1), article 5, open access; a plain-language survey of how zeta regularisation turns an infinite sum of zero-point energies into a finite, physical number, and where that method meets cosmology.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuumThe unified picture
Enrico Calloni
experimental physicist, Università di Napoli Federico II / INFN Napoli; leads the Archimedes experiment
ResearcherArchimedes asks the single most interesting question about the vacuum — does it weigh anything? — and Calloni is the person building the balance to find out.
- Archimedes: a feasibility study of an experiment to weigh the electromagnetic vacuum (2015) — Lead author on the scheme to measure the Earth's gravitational pull on a Casimir cavity — literally weighing the vacuum.
- The Archimedes project: a feasibility study for weighing the vacuum energy (2014) — The earlier project outline, using a high-precision balance and superconducting layers that expel or absorb vacuum energy.
- Progress in a Vacuum Weight Search Experiment (2020) — Status report on the balance and its noise budget in the journal Physics.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuum
Eric Weinstein
Mathematician and podcast host; public commentator on stalled fundamental physics, and author of the Geometric Unity proposal
CriticThe site's own 'what to watch' on dark energy is his prediction, and a person the canon leans on belongs in the directory. He is also the clearest voice for the position that the problem in fundamental physics is institutional as much as technical.
- The Portal (2019) — The interview series in which he argues that fundamental physics has been stalled for decades and says why.
- On-record prediction that the cosmological-constant term breaks at five sigma in DESI (2026) — A dated, falsifiable prediction about a live dataset - which is why the site is on record about it in advance.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isThe vacuum as a quantum fluid
Frank Wilczek
Nobel laureate in physics (2004); Herman Feshbach Professor of Physics, MIT
ResearcherA Nobel laureate who says openly that empty space is a material with properties, and who is now co-authoring the experiments that put that claim to work.
- Evidence for vacuum-enhanced superconductivity in NbSe2 (2026) — Co-developed the Ginzburg-Landau model in which the superconducting state exchanges virtual photons with the dark cavity, lowering its energy.
- Chiral Casimir Forces: Repulsive, Enhanced, Tunable (2019) — With Qing-Dong Jiang, showed how to make the Casimir force push instead of pull.
- Fundamentals: Ten Keys to Reality (2021) — His plain-language account of what the modern vacuum actually is — a material with properties, not an absence.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuumGravity control and superconductorsThe unified picture
Helge Kragh
Historian of physics who traces where the idea of vacuum energy actually came from
JournalistKragh shows the vacuum-energy idea is a century old and arrived by a much stranger route than the textbooks suggest — useful context for judging which modern claims are genuinely new.
- Preludes to dark energy: Zero-point energy and vacuum speculations (2011) — 69 pages, submitted to Archive for History of Exact Sciences; follows the trail from Walther Nernst's 1916 cosmological zero-point energy hypothesis to the moment in the late 1960s when vacuum energy and the cosmological constant were finally joined.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isThe unified picture
Jérôme Martin
Paris cosmologist, author of the fullest technical walk-through of the cosmological constant problem
ResearcherMartin does the arithmetic nobody else shows you — including the surprise that the headline mismatch shrinks a lot once the vacuum energy is renormalised properly.
- Everything You Always Wanted To Know About The Cosmological Constant Problem (But Were Afraid To Ask) (2012) — 89 pages, published in Comptes Rendus Physique 13, 566; works through regularisation in flat and curved spacetime and shows that the famous '122 orders of magnitude' figure is not what a careful renormalisation actually gives.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumThe unified picture
Lawrence M. Krauss
Theorist and popular writer on the energy of empty space, and an early advocate that Lambda is back
EducatorKrauss has spent thirty years arguing in public that empty space is not empty and that its energy dominates the universe — the popular framing most readers meet first.
- The Cosmological Constant is Back (1995) — With Michael S. Turner; Gen. Rel. Grav. 27, 1137-1144 — argued from pre-supernova data that the universe has a non-zero cosmological constant, and framed it explicitly as vacuum energy density.
- The Return of a Static Universe and the End of Cosmology (2007) — With Robert J. Scherrer; in a vacuum-energy-dominated future all evidence of expansion disappears from view — a striking argument about what vacuum energy does to knowledge itself.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isThe unified picture
Nemanja Kaloper
UC Davis theorist, co-inventor of vacuum energy sequestering
ProponentKaloper supplies the mathematical machinery for the boldest live idea in this corner: that gravity can be rewritten so it simply never sees the vacuum's energy, at any loop order.
- Sequestering the Standard Model Vacuum Energy (2014) — With Antonio Padilla; Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 091304 — makes dimensionful parameters in the matter sector depend on the four-volume of spacetime, which requires the universe to be finite and eventually to recollapse.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumThe unified picture
Qingdi Wang
Lead author of the fluctuating-vacuum-energy model of cosmic acceleration
ResearcherWang's calculation is the clearest worked example of a live idea worth following: that the vacuum's energy is real and gigantic, and that its violent fluctuation is precisely why the universe expands so gently.
- How the huge energy of quantum vacuum gravitates to drive the slow accelerating expansion of the Universe (2017) — First author with Zhen Zhu and W. G. Unruh; Phys. Rev. D 95, 103504. A published Comment by Mazzitelli and Trombetta (Phys. Rev. D 97, 068301, arXiv:1801.00138) and the authors' Reply are part of the same open exchange.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumThe unified picture
Raphael Bousso
Berkeley theorist who writes the lecture courses that teach the cosmological constant problem, and argues Lambda really is vacuum energy
ResearcherBousso is the clearest classroom voice on 'the energy of empty space' — his TASI notes turn a famously slippery problem into something a determined reader can actually follow.
- TASI Lectures on the Cosmological Constant (2008) — Published in Gen. Rel. Grav. 40, 607-637; opens with the plain statement that the vacuum's energy density is at least 60 orders of magnitude smaller than known contributions to it.
- The Cosmological Constant Problem, Dark Energy, and the Landscape of String Theory (2012) — A colloquium-level account arguing dark energy almost certainly is vacuum energy, and that a landscape of vacua could explain its size.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumThe unified picture
Robert L. Jaffe
MIT theorist whose short paper reframed what the Casimir effect does and does not prove about zero-point energy
CriticJaffe asks the question that has to be answered before any claim about extracting or weighing vacuum energy: does the Casimir plate experiment actually demonstrate that zero-point energy is real, or only that charged matter attracts? Anyone building on the vacuum should be able to answer him.
- The Casimir Effect and the Quantum Vacuum (2005) — Phys. Rev. D 72, 021301(R); shows the Casimir force can be derived entirely from charges and currents, and that it vanishes as the fine structure constant goes to zero.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isEnergy from the vacuum
Steven Weinberg
Nobel laureate whose 1989 review defined the cosmological constant problem for everyone who came after (died 2021 — archive entry)
ResearcherIf you read one thing before anything else about vacuum energy and gravity, read Weinberg 1989 — it is the map of the whole territory, written by the person who drew it, and every proposal since is measured against it.
- The cosmological constant problem (1989) — Rev. Mod. Phys. 61, 1-23; lays out why quantum field theory's estimate of the vacuum's energy overshoots what gravity actually feels, and surveys five families of possible answers.
- Anthropic bound on the cosmological constant (1987) — Phys. Rev. Lett. 59, 2607; argued a bound on Lambda from the requirement that galaxies form at all — the paper that made selection arguments respectable in cosmology.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumThe unified picture
Ulf Leonhardt
theoretical physicist, Weizmann Institute of Science; quantum vacuum and analogue gravity
ResearcherHe is the clearest thinker on the biggest version of the question: if vacuum energy is real, what does it do to spacetime — and can we watch a laboratory version of it?
- Backreaction of stimulated Hawking radiation in an optical analogue (2026) — Nature 655, 336–341 — vacuum-driven radiation in a laboratory analogue of a black-hole horizon (arXiv:2607.01118).
- Quantum noise in time-dependent media and cosmic expansion (2024) — Connects vacuum noise in changing media to the physics of an expanding universe (arXiv:2501.02495).
- Einstein's equations in electromagnetic media (2026) — EPL 154, 16003 — the geometry-as-material idea that connects vacuum physics to spacetime (arXiv:2508.11300).
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumEnergy from the vacuumThe unified pictureThe vacuum as a quantum fluid
Walther Nernst
Physical chemist and physicist (1864-1941); Nobel laureate in chemistry, 1920; the first to treat Planck's zero-point term as a real, universe-filling vacuum field
ResearcherThe directory carried the modern chain - Puthoff, Haisch, Rueda - without its origin. The zero-point field is not a recent idea: Planck's second radiation paper of 1911 introduced the term and Nernst, in 1916, took it seriously as a real field filling space and carried it to Einstein. A century of provenance makes the modern claim stronger, not weaker.
- Uber einen Versuch, von quantentheoretischen Betrachtungen zur Annahme stetiger Energieanderungen zuruckzukehren (1916) — The 1916 paper that made the zero-point term a physical vacuum field filling all space, and estimated its density. The reference line is as printed in the Peebles & Ratra review's bibliography.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuum
William G. Unruh
UBC theorist proposing that the vacuum's huge energy does gravitate — just not the way everyone assumed
ResearcherUnruh's group refuses the usual escape route of cancelling the vacuum energy away, and instead asks what an enormous, wildly fluctuating vacuum would really do to spacetime.
- How the huge energy of quantum vacuum gravitates to drive the slow accelerating expansion of the Universe (2017) — With Qingdi Wang and Zhen Zhu; Phys. Rev. D 95, 103504, a PRD Editors' Suggestion — take the enormous vacuum energy density seriously, let it fluctuate, and the net effect is a slow expansion rather than an instant catastrophe.
- Experimental Black-Hole Evaporation? (1981) — The paper that started analogue gravity: sound in a flowing fluid obeys the same equations as light near a horizon.
- Measurement of Stimulated Hawking Emission in an Analogue System (2011) — With Weinfurtner and colleagues, the water-tank experiment that measured the effect he predicted thirty years earlier.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isInertia and gravity from the vacuumThe unified pictureThe vacuum as a quantum fluid
Svend E. Rugh & Henrik Zinkernagel
Philosophers of physics who ask what exactly is being assumed when we say the vacuum has energy
CriticTheir paper sharpens a question the equations cannot answer on their own: what would it actually mean for the vacuum's energy to be physically real, rather than a bookkeeping choice?
- The quantum vacuum and the cosmological constant problem (2002) — Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 33, 663-705 (arXiv hep-th/0012253); traces where the problem came from and asks which assumptions about general relativity and quantum field theory are needed to make it even well-posed.
The vacuum at cosmic scaleWhat the vacuum isThe unified picture
10 · Inertia and gravity from the vacuum
Heidi Fearn
theoretical physicist, California State University Fullerton; director of physics research, Space Studies Institute
ProponentCarries Woodward's programme forward and is unusually clear about which measurements would kill it.
- Mach Effect Gravitational Assist Drive (2018) — The design and theory of the PZT-stack MEGA thruster.
- Mach Effects for In Space Propulsion: Interstellar Mission (NIAC Phase II) (2018) — The NASA-funded study that took Mach-effect propulsion into a formal advanced-concepts programme.
- New Stick-Slip Tests of the Mach Effect Gravitational Assist (MEGA) Drive (2018) — Presented at an APS meeting - the effort to rule out mechanical artefacts.
Inertia and gravity from the vacuumInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
James F. Woodward
physicist, professor emeritus, California State University Fullerton; originator of Mach-effect propulsion
ProponentThe one propellantless-thrust proposal derived from accepted physics rather than around it - and he wrote down exactly how to falsify it.
- Making Starships and Stargates: The Science of Interstellar Transport and Absurdly Benign Wormholes (2013) — The full argument that transient mass fluctuations, allowed by Mach's principle, make propellantless thrust legal.
- A new experimental approach to Mach's principle and relativistic gravitation (1990) — The original derivation of the transient mass fluctuation term (Foundations of Physics Letters 3, 497).
- Mach Effect Gravitational Assist Drive (SSI report) (2018) — With Fearn; the NIAC-era statement of the MEGA drive design.
Inertia and gravity from the vacuumInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craftThe metric, warp drives and wormholes
Jean-Pierre Petit
French astrophysicist (CNRS, ret.); magnetohydrodynamic propulsion and the bimetric 'Janus' cosmological model
ResearcherPetit is the one senior French plasma physicist who took MHD propulsion and negative-mass gravity from the lab bench to a public French curriculum – if you want the metric-engineering argument in French, you start here.
- Le Modèle Janus pour les Nuls (2025) — 115,464 views; Petit's own plain-French introduction to the bimetric negative-mass model.
- Lecture on the cosmological model JANUS (2023) — 169,434 views; the fullest technical statement of the Janus metric.
- JANUS 35 – Les trous noirs (2023) — 110,965 views; his challenge to the black-hole interpretation from the bimetric side.
Inertia and gravity from the vacuumThe metric, warp drives and wormholesInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craftThe unified picture
Mike McCulloch
lecturer in geomatics, University of Plymouth; originator of quantised inertia (QI)
ProponentTurns 'inertia comes from the vacuum and the horizon' into numbers you can test on a galaxy and on a bench - and DARPA funded the test.
- Minimum accelerations from quantised inertia (2010) — The core prediction: inertia weakens at very low acceleration because the Unruh wavelength no longer fits the observable horizon.
- Testing quantised inertia on the emdrive (2016) — Turns QI into a concrete thruster prediction, which is what made hardware programmes possible.
- Physics from the Edge: A New Cosmological Model for Inertia (2014) — The book-length statement of horizon-based inertia for a general technical reader.
Inertia and gravity from the vacuumInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
Physical Review A as the venue for the inertia debate
the mainstream journal in which the zero-point-field inertia claim was both made and answered
EducatorThe cleanest worked example on this whole site of how a radical claim gets made, tested and argued in the open literature.
- Inertia as a zero-point-field Lorentz force (1994) — Haisch, Rueda and Puthoff make the claim.
- Inertia as a zero-point-field force: Critical analysis of the Haisch-Rueda-Puthoff inertia theory (2009) — Levin answers it in the same journal - read the pair together.
Inertia and gravity from the vacuumThe evidence ladderEnergy from the vacuum
Steven Hampton
Researcher documenting the Dean Drive and inertial-impulse patent literature
ProponentThe Dean Drive is the origin story of inertial propulsion claims; reading the patents is how you find out what was really claimed.
- Patent secrets of inertial propulsion – Dean Drive impulse engine (2026) — The channel's stated subject: what the Dean Drive patents actually specify.
Inertia and gravity from the vacuumInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
Thomas (Tom) Banks
Rutgers theorist who argues the size of the cosmological constant is fixed by the quantum structure of spacetime itself
ResearcherBanks flips the usual question: instead of asking why vacuum energy is small, he asks what a universe with a small positive Lambda tells us about how many quantum states spacetime can hold.
- My Personal History With the Quantum Theory of de Sitter Space (2023) — An 11-page first-person account of how the quantum theory of de Sitter space developed — an unusually readable way into why Banks thinks Lambda is an input, not an accident.
EarthTech International / Institute for Advanced Studies at Austin
private research institute in Austin, Texas devoted to quantum vacuum, spacetime and propulsion physics
ProponentA rare thing: a privately funded laboratory that has taken the quantum vacuum seriously as an energy and propulsion question for forty years and publishes what it finds.
- Institute for Advanced Studies at Austin research programme (1991) — A standing private laboratory whose declared interests are the quantum vacuum, modifications to electrodynamics, spacetime and gravity, and interstellar flight.
- EarthTech publications list (2026) — The institute's own bibliography of vacuum, gravity and propulsion papers.
- Institute for Advanced Studies at Austin (1985) — Founded by Harold Puthoff in 1985; incorporated under EarthTech International in 1991.
Inertia and gravity from the vacuumThe metric, warp drives and wormholesEnergy from the vacuumWhat the vacuum isScalar waves and the field behind the fields
Inertial Propulsion Research Laboratory
Long-running experimental channel on non-rocket, inertial propulsion devices
ResearcherThree hundred experiments is a data set – far more useful to chapter three than any single dramatic claim.
- Inertial propulsion experiment archive (2026) — 301 videos; one of the deepest continuous experimental records on inertial drives.
Inertia and gravity from the vacuumInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craft
TU Dresden Chair of Space Systems (Martin Tajmar group)
University chair that independently tests claimed breakthrough propulsion effects on high-precision thrust balances
ResearcherWhen an extraordinary thrust claim appears, this is the lab that measures it properly - which is exactly what makes the surviving claims worth attention.
- High-precision thrust balance replications of claimed propellantless thrusters (2021) — Tajmar's group is the standing independent check on breakthrough propulsion claims, and reports null results as readily as positive ones.
Inertia and gravity from the vacuumInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craftGravity control and superconductors
Zero-Point Field Technologies LLC (ZPF Technologies)
Houston start-up founded by Douglas Miller, designing a MEMS/microchip Casimir cavity intended to exchange momentum with the zero-point field, built explicitly on stochastic electrodynamics
ProponentZPF Technologies is Zero-Point Field Technologies LLC, founded by Douglas Miller - not by Gabriel Dias, who presents his own 'ZPF Tech' research at APEC and collaborates on the chip. Worth reading because the company frames its device as a falsifiable test of stochastic electrodynamics rather than a finished product, and because Miller is the coiner of 'vacuum-catalysed fusion' who narrowed his own term in public on 8 September 2026. His is the only design in the field that physically moves its boundaries rather than modulating them electronically, and its stated purpose is measurement before power.
- MEMS array engineering design package (2025) — The company states the chip 'will only work if SED is true', which makes it a genuine falsifiable test rather than a claim.
- Advancing Zero-Point Energy Navigation (2025) — Builds on the Haisch-Rueda-Puthoff inertia model and Setterfield's varying-constants ideas.
- Presentations on stochastic electrodynamics and quantum vacuum propulsion (2026) — The venture's own channels: talks on the framework behind the Haisch-Rueda-Puthoff inertia work, from the people trying to build hardware from it.
Inertia and gravity from the vacuumEnergy from the vacuumInertial mass reduction, the Navy patents and transmedium craftWhat the vacuum is