The Spacetime Metric

Historical research guide · 0793 · 1903

On the partial differential equations of mathematical physics

E. T. Whittaker

In one minute

This is the paper that shows how much structure is hidden inside the two great equations of classical physics. Whittaker proves that every solution of Laplace’s equation — the equation of any gravitational or electrostatic potential — can be written as a single integral of one arbitrary function around a circle of directions, and that every solution of the wave equation can be written as a double integral of one arbitrary function over all directions in space. The consequence he draws from the second result is the famous one: any wave disturbance whatever, including a static field, can be decomposed into ordinary plane waves running in every direction at once. He then builds a set of spherical waves, emitted at every wavelength, that interfere so exactly that the total disturbance never changes with time and falls off precisely as one over the distance. A steady gravitational field, on this reading, is a standing pattern of waves in the medium — and gravity is propagated at a finite speed, which Whittaker notes may be enormously greater than that of light.

Connection

Chapter 10 follows the tradition that treats the potentials as physical structure rather than bookkeeping, and this paper is where that tradition starts: Whittaker shows a static field is mathematically identical to a superposition of travelling waves. Chapter 2’s picture of a vacuum that carries structure is exactly the medium he is describing, and his companion 1904 paper reducing the whole electromagnetic field to two scalar functions is the other half of the argument.

From the source

  1. The general solution of Laplace’s equation in three dimensions is a single integral around a circle of directions: the integral, over u from zero to two pi, of an arbitrary function of just two arguments — the complex combination z plus i x cos u plus i y sin u, and the angle u itself. Whittaker proves this is completely general, assuming only that some branch of the solution is regular at some point, and notes that it is the three-dimensional analogue of the two-dimensional theorem that every solution of Laplace’s equation in the plane is a function of x plus i y added to a function of x minus i y.Section 2, The general solution of the potential equation, pp. 333–337

  2. The solution has a concrete reading. Regarding the definite integral as the limit of a sum, the general solution is the sum of an infinite number of elementary constituents, each one a solution of a two-dimensional Laplace equation referred to axes obtained from the original axes by a simple rotation about the axis of z. The known particular solutions are recovered as special cases: to expand any solution in Legendre harmonics one need only expand the arbitrary function as a Taylor series in its first argument and a Fourier series in its second, and to expand it in Bessel terms one expands the same function in exponentials of the first argument and a Fourier series in the second.Section 3, points 1, 2 and 3, pp. 337–342

  3. The same method gives the general solution of the equation of wave-motions. Every solution is a double integral over the directions of space — u from zero to pi and v from zero to two pi — of an arbitrary function of three arguments: the projection x sin u cos v plus y sin u sin v plus z cos u, added to the time divided by the wave-speed constant, together with the two angles u and v that name the direction.Section 4, The differential equation of wave-motions, pp. 342–345

  4. From that general solution follows the theorem the paper is remembered for: the general finite solution of the differential equation of wave-motions can be analysed into simple uniform plane waves, one for every direction in space and every wavelength. Whittaker observes that Johnstone Stoney had shown in 1897, by physical reasoning and without any reference to the equation, that all the disturbances of the luminiferous ether arising from sources of certain kinds can be resolved into trains of plane waves.Section 5, point 1, The analysis of wave-motions, pp. 346–347

  5. Two further results are drawn out. The reduced wave equation — what is now called the Helmholtz equation, obtained when the time dependence is a single frequency — has as its general solution the double integral over all directions of an exponential of i times the projection along that direction, weighted by an arbitrary function of the two angles; and the known spherical solutions, a Bessel function of half-odd order divided by the square root of the radius multiplied by an associated Legendre function of the polar angle, drop out of it. Whittaker also defines a family of generalised Bessel functions by a double Laurent expansion, shows that each satisfies the same equation, gives them an integral representation that is the analogue of Bessel’s integral, proves an addition theorem for them, and uses them for an alternative analysis of the general solution as a double series with arbitrary constants.Section 5, points 2, 3 and 4, pp. 347–353

  6. Whittaker’s closing section, Gravitation and electrostatic attraction explained as modes of wave-disturbance. Because an inverse-square potential satisfies Laplace’s equation it satisfies the wave equation for any constant, so it can be analysed into simple plane waves, each propagated with constant velocity, which interfere in such a way that once the action has been set up the disturbance at any point does not vary with the time. He constructs the case explicitly: a particle emitting spherical waves of every wavelength, with a stated amplitude law, sums to a total disturbance that is independent of the time and everywhere proportional to the gravitational potential of that particle. In each constituent field the potential is constant along the wave-front, so the force is perpendicular to it and the waves are longitudinal. This assimilates the propagation of gravity to that of light, and requires that gravity be propagated with a finite velocity — which, he adds, need not be the same as that of light and may be enormously greater. He is explicit that the investigation does not explain the cause of gravity.Section 5, point 5, pp. 353–355

The way in

https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01444290

How to cite it

E. T. Whittaker (1903) On the partial differential equations of mathematical physics doi:10.1007/BF01444290

Where it sits in the curriculum

Provenance: Retrieved 2026-09-08

Summary by: The Spacetime Metric editorial rail (AI draft from the source text, 2026-09-07)

← The library